"It undoubtedly needs,"
Peter Stanhope said, "a final pulling together, but there's hardly
time for that before July, and if you're willing to take it as it
is, why——" He made a gesture of presentation and dropped his eyes,
thus missing the hasty reciprocal gesture of gratitude with which
Mrs. Parry immediately replied on behalf of the dramatic culture of
Battle Hill. Behind and beyond her the culture, some thirty faces,
unessentially exhibited to each other by the May sunlight, settled
to attention—naturally, efficiently, critically, solemnly,
reverently. The grounds of the Manor House expanded beyond them;
the universal sky sustained the whole. Peter Stanhope began to read
his play.
Battle Hill was one of the new
estates which had been laid out after the war. It lay about thirty
miles north of London and took its title from the more ancient name
of the broad rise of ground which it covered. It had a quiet
ostentation of comfort and culture. The poor, who had created it,
had been as far as possible excluded, nor (except as hired
servants) were they permitted to experience the bitterness of
others' stairs. The civil wars which existed there, however bitter,
were conducted with all bourgeois propriety. Politics, religion,
art, science, grouped themselves, and courteously competed for
numbers and reputation. This summer, however, had seen a
spectacular triumph of drama, for it had become known that Peter
Stanhope had consented to allow the restless talent of the Hill to
produce his latest play.
He was undoubtedly the most
famous inhabitant. He was a cadet of that family which had owned
the Manor House, and he had bought it back from more recent
occupiers, and himself settled in it before the war. He had been
able to do this because he was something more than a cadet of good
family, being also a poet in the direct English line, and so much
after the style of his greatest predecessor that he made money out
of poetry. His name was admired by his contemporaries and respected
by the young. He had even imposed modern plays in verse on the
London theatre, and two of them tragedies at that, with a farce or
two, and histories for variation and pleasure. He was the kind of
figure who might be more profitable to his neighbourhood dead than
alive; dead, he would have given it a shrine; alive, he deprecated
worshippers. The young men at the estate office made a refined
publicity out of his privacy; the name of Peter Stanhope would be
whispered without comment. He endured the growing invasion with a
great deal of good humour, and was content to see the hill of his
birth become a suburb of the City, as in another sense it would
always be. There was, in that latest poetry, no contention between
the presences of life and of death; so little indeed that there had
been a contention in the Sunday Times whether Stanhope were a
pessimist or an optimist. He himself said, in reply to an
interviewer's question, that he was an optimist and hated it.
Stanhope, though the most
glorious, was not the only notorious figure of the Hill. There was
Mr. Lawrence Wentworth, who was the most distinguished living
authority on military history (perhaps excepting Mr. Aston
Moffatt). Mr. Wentworth was not in the garden on that afternoon.
Mrs. Catherine Parry was; it was she who would produce the play, as
in many places and at many times she had produced others. She sat
near Stanhope now, almost as tall as he, and with more active
though not brighter eyes. They were part of that presence which was
so necessary to her profession. Capacity which, in her nature, had
reached the extreme of active life, seemed in him to have entered
the contemplative, so much had his art become a thing of his soul.
Where, in their own separate private affairs, he interfered so
little as almost to seem inefficient, she was so efficient as
almost to seem interfering.
In the curve of women and men
beyond her, other figures, less generally famous, sat or lay as the
depth of their chairs induced them. There were rising young men,
and a few risen and retired old. There were ambitious young women
and sullen young women and loquacious young women. They were all
attentive, though, as a whole, a little disappointed. They had
understood that Mr. Stanhope had been writing a comedy, and had
hoped for a modern comedy. When he had been approached, however, he
had been easy but firm. He had been playing with a pastoral; if
they would like a pastoral, it was very much at their service.
Hopes and hints of modern comedies were unrealized: it was the
pastoral or nothing. They had to be content. He consented to read
it to them; he would not do more. He declined to make suggestions
for the cast; he declined to produce. He would like, for his own
enjoyment, to come to some of the rehearsals, but he made it clear
that he had otherwise no wish to interfere. Nothing—given the
necessity of a pastoral—could be better; the production would have
all the advantage of his delayed death without losing any advantage
of his prolonged life. As this became clear, the company grew
reconciled. They gazed and listened, while from the long lean
figure, outstretched in its deck-chair, there issued the complex
intonation of great verse. Never negligible, Stanhope was often
neglected; he was everyone's second thought, but no one's first.
The convenience of all had determined this afternoon that he should
be the first, and his neat mass of grey hair, his vivid glance,
that rose sometimes from the manuscript, and floated down the rows,
and sank again, his occasional friendly gesture that seemed about
to deprecate, but always stopped short, received the concentration
of his visitors, and of Mrs. Parry, the chief of his
visitors.
It became clear to Mrs. Parry, as
the afternoon and the voice went on, that the poet had been quite
right when he had said that the play needed pulling together. "It's
all higgledy-piggledy," she said to herself, using a word which a
friend had once applied to a production of the Tempest, and in fact
to the Tempest itself. Mrs. Parry thought that this pastoral was,
in some ways, rather like the Tempest. Mr. Stanhope, of course, was
not as good as Shakespeare, because Shakespeare was the greatest
English poet, so that Stanhope wasn't. But there was a something.
To begin with, it had no title beyond A Pastoral. That was
unsatisfactory. Then the plot was incredibly loose. It was of no
particular time and no particular place, and to any cultured
listener it seemed to have little bits of everything and everybody
put in at odd moments. The verse was undoubtedly Stanhope's own, of
his latest, most heightened, and most epigrammatic style, but now
and then all kinds of reminiscences moved in it. Once, during the
second act, the word pastiche floated through Mrs. Parry's mind,
but went away again on her questioning whether a pastiche would be
worth the trouble of production. There was a Grand Duke in it, who
had a beautiful daughter, and this daughter either escaped from the
palace or was abducted—anyhow, she came into the power of a number
of brigands; and then there was a woodcutter's son who frequently
burned leaves, and he and the princess fell in love, and there were
two farmers who were at odds, and the Grand Duke turned up in
disguise, first in a village and then in the forest, through which
also wandered an escaped bear, who spoke the most complex verse of
all, excepting the Chorus. The Chorus had no kind of other name; at
first Mrs. Parry thought they might be villagers, then, since they
were generally present in the forest, she thought they might be
trees, or perhaps (with a vague reminiscence of Comus) spirits.
Stanhope had not been very helpful; he had alluded to them as an
experiment. By the end of the reading, it was clear to Mrs. Parry
that it was very necessary to decide what exactly this Chorus was
to be.
She had discouraged discussion of
the play during the intervals between the four acts, and as soon as
it was over tea was served. If, however, the poet hoped to get away
from discussion by means of tea he was mistaken. There was a little
hesitation over the correct word; fantastic was dangerous, and
poetic both unpopular and supererogatory, though both served for
variations on idyllic, which was Mrs. Parry's choice and won by
lengths. As she took her second cup of tea, however, she began to
close. She said: "Yes, idyllic, Mr. Stanhope, and so
significant!"
"It's very good of you," Stanhope
murmured. "But you see I was right about revision—the plot must
seem very loose."
Mrs. Parry waved the plot up into
benevolence. "But there are a few points," she went on. "The Chorus
now. I don't think I follow the Chorus."
"The Chorus could be omitted,"
Stanhope said. "It's not absolutely necessary to a
presentation."
Before Mrs. Parry could answer, a
young woman named Adela Hunt, sitting close by, leant forward. She
was the leader of the younger artistic party, who were not
altogether happy about Mrs. Parry. Adela had some thoughts of
taking up production herself as her life-work, and it would have
been a great advantage to have started straight away with Peter
Stanhope. But her following was not yet strong enough to deal with
Mrs. Parry's reputation. She was determined, however, if possible,
to achieve a kind of collaboration by means of correction. "O, we
oughtn't to omit anything, ought we?" she protested. "A work of art
can't spare anything that's a part of it."
"My dear," Mrs. Parry said, "you
must consider your audience. What will the audience make of the
Chorus?"
"It's for them to make what they
can of it," Adela answered. "We can only give them a symbol. Art's
always symbolic, isn't it?"
Mrs. Parry pursed her lips. "I
wouldn't say symbolic exactly," she said slowly. "It has a
significance, of course, and you've got to convey that significance
to the audience. We want to present it—to interpret."
As she paused, distracted by the
presentation by the poet of two kinds of sandwiches, Adela broke in
again.
"But, Mrs. Parry, how can one
interpret a symbol? One can only mass it. It's all of a piece, and
it's the total effect that creates the symbolical force."
"Significant, not symbolical,"
said Mrs. Parry firmly. "You mustn't play down to your audience,
but you mustn't play away from them either. You must"—she
gesticulated—"intertwine … harmonize. So you must make it easy for
them to get into harmony. That's what's wrong with a deal of modern
art; it refuses—it doesn't establish equilibrium with its audience
or what not. In a pastoral play you must have equilibrium."
"But the equilibrium's in the
play," Adela urged again, "a balance of masses. Surely that's what
drama is—a symbolical contrast of masses."
"Well," Mrs. Parry answered with
infuriating tolerance, "I suppose you might call it that. But it's
more effective to think of it as significant equilibrium—especially
for a pastoral. However, don't let's be abstract. The question is,
what's to be done about the Chorus? Had we better keep it in or
leave it out? Which would you prefer, Mr. Stanhope?"
"I should prefer it in, if you
ask me," Stanhope said politely. "But not to inconvenience the
production."
"It seems to be in the forest so
often," Mrs. Parry mused, dismissing cake. "There's the distant
song in the first act, when the princess goes away from the palace,
and the choric dialogue when…. It isn't Dryads, is it?"
A friend of Adela's, a massive
and superb young man of twenty-five, offered a remark. "Dryads
would rather wreck the eighteenth century, wouldn't they?"
"Watteau," said a young lady near
Adela. "You could have them period."
Mrs. Parry looked at her
approvingly. "Exactly, my dear," she said. "A very charming fantasy
it might be; we must take care it isn't precious—only period. But,
Mr. Stanhope, you haven't told us—are they Dryads?"
"Actually," Stanhope answered,
"as I told you, it's more an experiment than anything else. The
main thing is—was—that they are non-human."
"Spirits?" said the Watteau young
lady with a trill of pleasure.
"If you like," said Stanhope,
"only not spiritual. Alive, but with a different life—even from the
princess."
"Irony?" Adela exclaimed. "It's a
kind of comment, isn't it, Mr. Stanhope, on futility? The forest
and everything, and the princess and her lover—so
transitory."
Stanhope shook his head. There
was a story, invented by himself, that The Times had once sent a
representative to ask for explanations about a new play, and that
Stanhope, in his efforts to explain it, had found after four hours
that he had only succeeded in reading it completely through aloud:
"Which," he maintained, "was the only way of explaining it."
"No," he said now, "not irony. I
think perhaps you'd better cut them out."
There was a moment's pause. "But
we can't do that, Mr. Stanhope," said a voice; "they're important
to the poetry, aren't they?" It was the voice of another young
woman, sitting behind Adela. Her name was Pauline Anstruther, and,
compared with Adela, she was generally silent. Now, after her quick
question, she added hastily, "I mean—they come in when the princess
and the wood-cutter come together, don't they?" Stanhope looked at
her, and she felt as if his eyes had opened suddenly. He said, more
slowly:
"In a way, but they needn't. We
could just make it chance."
"I don't think that would be
nearly as satisfactory," Mrs. Parry said. "I begin to see my
way—the trees perhaps—leaves—to have the leaves of the wood all so
helpful to the young people—so charming!"
"It's a terribly sweet idea,"
said the Watteau young lady. "And so true too!"
Pauline, who was sitting next
her, said in an undertone: "True?"
"Don't you think so?" Watteau,
whose actual name was Myrtle Fox, asked. "It's what I always
feel—about trees and flowers and leaves and so on—they're so
friendly. Perhaps you don't notice it so much; I'm rather mystic
about nature. Like Wordsworth. I should love to spend days out with
nothing but the trees and the leaves and the wind. Only somehow one
never seems to have time. But I do believe they're all breathing in
with us, and it's such a comfort—here, where there are so many
trees. Of course, we've only to sink into ourselves to find
peace—and trees and clouds and so on all help us. One never need be
unhappy. Nature's so terribly good. Don't you think so, Mr.
Stanhope?"
Stanhope was standing by, silent,
while Mrs. Parry communed with her soul and with one or two of her
neighbours on the possibilities of dressing the Chorus. He turned
his head and answered, "That Nature is terribly good? Yes, Miss
Fox. You do mean 'terribly'?"
"Why, certainly," Miss Fox said.
"Terribly—dreadfully—very."
"Yes," Stanhope said again.
"Very. Only—you must forgive me; it comes from doing so much
writing, but when I say 'terribly' I think I mean 'full of terror'.
A dreadful goodness."
"I don't see how goodness can be
dreadful," Miss Fox said, with a shade of resentment in her voice.
"If things are good they're not terrifying, are they?"
"It was you who said 'terribly',"
Stanhope reminded her with a smile, "I only agreed."
"And if things are terrifying,"
Pauline put in, her eyes half-closed and her head turned away as if
she asked a casual question rather of the world than of him, "can
they be good?"
He looked down on her. "Yes,
surely," he said, with more energy. "Are our tremors to measure the
Omnipotence?"
"We'll have them in shades of
green then," Mrs. Parry broke in, "light to dark, with rich gold
sashes and embroidery running all over like twigs, and each one
carrying a conventionalized bough—different lengths, I think. Dark
gold stockings."
"To suggest the trunks?" asked
Adela's friend Hugh Prescott.
"Quite," Mrs. Parry said, and
then hesitated. "I'm not sure—perhaps we'd better keep the leaf
significances. When they're still—of course they could stand with
their legs twined…."
"What, with one another's?" Adela
asked, in a conscious amazement.
"My dear child, don't be absurd,"
Mrs. Parry said. "Each pair of legs just crossed, so"—she
interlaced her own.
"I could never stand still like
that," Miss Fox said, with great conviction.
"You'd have your arms stretched
out to people's shoulders on each side," Mrs. Parry said dubiously,
"and a little gentle swaying wouldn't be inappropriate. But perhaps
we'd better not risk it. Better have green stockings—we can manage
some lovely groupings. Could we call them 'Chorus of Leaf-Spirits',
Mr. Stanhope?"
"Sweet!" said Miss Fox. Adela,
leaning back to Hugh Prescott, said in a very low voice, "I told
you, Hugh, she'll ruin the whole thing. She's got no idea of mass.
She ought to block it violently and leave it without a name. I
wouldn't even have 'Chorus'. I hope he won't give way, but he's
rather weak."
However, Stanhope was, in the
politest language, declining to have anything of the sort. "Call it
the Chorus," he said, "or if you like I'll try and find a name for
the leader, and the rest can just dance and sing. But I'm afraid
'Leaf-Spirits' would be misleading."
"What about 'Chorus of
Nature-Powers'?" asked Miss Fox, but Stanhope only said, smiling,
"You will try and make the trees friendly," which no one quite
understood, and shook his head again.
Prescott asked: "Incidentally, I
suppose they will be women?"
Mrs. Parry had said, "O, of
course, Mr. Prescott," before the question reached her brain. When
it did, she added, "At least … I naturally took it for granted….
They are feminine, aren't they?"
Still hankering after mass, Adela
said, "It sounds to me more like undifferentiated sex force," and
ignored Hugh's murmur, "There isn't much fun in that."
"I don't know that they were
meant to be either male or female," Stanhope said. "I told you they
were more of an experiment in a different kind of existence. But
whether men or women are most like that is another matter." He shed
an apologetic smile on Mrs. Parry.
"If they're going to be leaves,"
Miss Fox asked, "couldn't they all wear huge leaves, so that no one
would know if they were wearing knee-breeches or skirts?"
There was a pause while everyone
took this in, then Mrs. Parry said, very firmly, "I don't think
that would answer," while Hugh Prescott said to Adela, "Chorus of
Fig-leaves!"
"Why not follow the old pantomime
or the present musical comedy," Stanhope asked, "and dress your
feminine chorus in exquisite masculine costume? That's what
Shakespeare did with his heroines, as often as he could, and made a
diagram of something more sharp and wonderful than either. I don't
think you'll do better. Masculine voices—except boys—would hardly
do, nor feminine appearances."
Mrs. Parry sighed, and everyone
contemplated the problem again. Adela Hunt and Hugh Prescott
discussed modernity between themselves. Pauline, lying back, like
Stanhope, in her chair, was thinking of Stanhope's phrases, "a
different life", "a terrible good", and wondering if they were
related, if this Chorus over which they were spending so much
trouble were indeed an effort to shape in verse a good so alien as
to be terrifying. She had never considered good as a thing of
terror, and certainly she had not supposed a certain thing of
terror in her own secret life as any possible good. Nor now; yet
there had been an inhumanity in the great and moving lines of the
Chorus. She thought, with an anger generous in its origin but proud
and narrow in its conclusion, that not many of the audience really
cared for poetry or for Stanhope's poetry—perhaps none but she. He
was a great poet, one of a very few, but what would he do if one
evening he met himself coming up the drive? Doppelgänger, the
learned called it, which was no comfort. Another poet had thought
of it; she had had to learn the lines at school, as an extra task
because of undone work:
The Magus Zoroaster, my dead
child
Met his own image walking in the
garden.
She had never done the
imposition, for she had had nightmares that night, after reading
the lines, and had to go sick for days. But she had always hated
Shelley since for making it so lovely, when it wasn't loveliness
but black panic. Shelley never seemed to suggest that the good
might be terrible. What would Peter Stanhope do? what could he? if
he met himself?
They were going: people were
getting up and moving off. Everyone was being agreeably grateful to
Stanhope for his lawn, his tea, and his poetry. In her fear of
solitude she attached herself to Adela and Hugh and Myrtle Fox, who
were all saying good-bye at once. As he shook hands he said
casually: "You don't think they are?" and she did not immediately
understand the reference to the measurement of Omnipotence by
mortal tremors. Her mind was on Myrtle, who lived near her. She
hated the pang of gratitude she felt, and hated it more because she
despised Miss Fox. But at least she wouldn't be alone, and the
thing she hated most only came, or had so far only come, when she
was alone. She stuck close to Myrtle, listening to Adela as they
went.
"Pure waste," Adela was saying.
"Of course, Stanhope's dreadfully traditional"—how continually,
Pauline thought, people misused words like dreadful; if they knew
what dread was!—"but he's got a kind of weight, only he dissipates
it. He undermines his mass. Don't you think so, Pauline?"
"I don't know," Pauline said
shortly, and then added with private and lying malice: "I'm no
judge of literature."
"Perhaps not," Adela said,
"though I think it's more a question of general sensitiveness.
Hugh, did you notice how the Parry talked of significance? Why, no
one with a really adult mind could possibly—— O, good-bye, Pauline;
I may see you to-morrow." Her voice passed away, accompanied by
Hugh's temporary and lazy silence, and Pauline was left to Myrtle's
monologues on the comforting friendliness of sunsets.
Even that had to stop when they
reached the Foxes' hole. Myrtle, in a spasm of friendship for
Messias, frequently called it that. As they parted upon the easy
joke, Pauline felt the rest of the sentence pierce her. She took it
to her with a sincerity of pain which almost excused the
annexation—"the Son of Man hath not where to lay his head." It was
the cry of her loneliness and fear, and it meant nothing to her
mind but the empty streets and that fear itself. She went on.
Not to think; to think of
something else. If she could. It was so hopeless. She was trying
not to look ahead for fear she saw it, and also to look ahead for
fear she was yielding to fear. She walked down the road quickly and
firmly, remembering the many thousand times it had not come. But
the visitation was increasing—growing nearer and clearer and more
frequent. In her first twenty-four years she had seen it nine
times; at first she had tried to speak of it. She had been told,
when she was small, not to be silly and not to be naughty. Once,
when she was adolescent, she had actually told her mother. Her
mother was understanding in most things, and knew it. But at this
the understanding had disappeared. Her eyes had become as sharp as
when her husband, by breaking his arm, had spoiled a holiday in
Spain which she—"for all their sakes"—had planned. She had refused
to speak any more to Pauline that day, and neither of them had ever
quite forgiven the other. But in those days the comings—as she
still called them—had been rare; since her parents had died and she
had been sent to live with and look after her grandmother in Battle
Hill they had been more frequent, as if the Hill was fortunate and
favourable to apparitions beyond men; a haunt of alien life. There
had been nine in two years, as many as in all the years before. She
could not speak of it to her grandmother, who was too old, nor to
anyone else, since she had never discovered any closeness of
friendship. But what would happen when the thing that was she came
up to her, and spoke or touched? So far it had always turned aside,
down some turning, or even apparently into some house; she might
have been deceived were it not for the chill in her blood. But if
some day it did not….
A maid came out of a house a
little farther down a road, and crossed the pavement to a
pillar-box. Pauline, in the first glance, felt the sickness at her
heart. Relieved, she reacted into the admission that she was only
twenty-three houses away from her home. She knew every one of them;
she had not avoided so much measurement of danger. It had never
appeared to her indoors; not even on the Hill, which seemed to be
so convenient for it. Sometimes she longed always to stay indoors;
it could not be done, nor would she do it. She drove herself out,
but the front door was still a goal and a protection. She always
seemed to herself to crouch and cling before she left it, coveting
the peace which everyone but she had … twenty-one, twenty…. She
would not run; she would not keep her eyes on the pavement. She
would walk steadily forward, head up and eyes before her …
seventeen, sixteen…. She would think of something, of Peter
Stanhope's play—"a terrible good". The whole world was for her a
canvas printed with unreal figures, a curtain apt to roll up at any
moment on one real figure. But this afternoon, under the stress of
the verse, and then under the shock of Stanhope's energetic speech,
she had fractionally wondered: a play—was there a play? a play even
that was known by some? and then not without peace … ten, nine …
the Magus Zoroaster; perhaps Zoroaster had not been frightened.
Perhaps if any of the great—if Cæsar had met his own shape in Rome,
or even Shelley … was there any tale of any who had?… six, five,
four….
Her heart sprang; there, a good
way off—thanks to a merciful God—it was, materialized from nowhere
in a moment. She knew it at once, however far, her own young
figure, her own walk, her own dress and hat—had not her first sight
of it been attracted so? changing, growing…. It was coming up at
her pace—doppelgänger, doppelgänger: her control began to give …
two … she didn't run, lest it should, nor did it. She reached her
gate, slipped through, went up the path. If it should be running
very fast up the road behind her now? She was biting back the
scream and fumbling for her key. Quiet, quiet! "A terrible good."
She got the key into the keyhole; she would not look back; would it
click the gate or not? The door opened; and she was in, and the
door banged behind her. She all but leant against it, only the
doppelgänger might be leaning similarly on the other side. She went
forward, her hand at her throat, up the stairs to her room,
desiring (and with every atom of energy left denying that her
desire could be vain) that there should be left to her still this
one refuge in which she might find shelter.