After
ushering his client out the hall door and closing it behind her,
Rand turned and said:
“All right, Kathie, or Dave;
whoever’s out there. Come on in.”
Then he went to his desk and
reached under it, snapping off a switch. As he straightened, the
door from the reception-office opened and his secretary, Kathie
O’Grady, entered, loading a cigarette into an eight-inch amber
holder. She was a handsome woman, built on the generous lines of a
Renaissance goddess; none of the Renaissance masters, however, had
ever employed a model so strikingly Hibernian. She had blue eyes,
and a fair, highly-colored complexion; she wore green, which went
well with her flaming red hair, and a good deal of gold
costume-jewelry.
Behind her came Dave Ritter. He
was Rand’s assistant, and also Kathie’s lover. He was five or six
years older than his employer, and slightly built. His hair,
fighting a stubborn rearguard action against baldness, was an
indeterminate mousy gray-brown. It was one of his professional
assets that nobody ever noticed him, not even in a crowd of one;
when he wanted it to, his thin face could assume the weary, baffled
expression of a middle-aged bookkeeper with a wife and four
children on fifty dollars a week. Actually, he drew three times
that much, had no wife, admitted to no children. During the war, he
and Kathie had kept the Tri-State Agency in something better than a
state of suspended animation while Rand had been in the Army.
Ritter fumbled a Camel out of his
shirt pocket and made a beeline for the desk, appropriating Rand’s
lighter and sharing the flame with Kathie.
“You know, Jeff,” he said, “one
of the reasons why this agency never made any money while you were
away was that I never had the unadulterated insolence to ask the
kind of fees you do. I was listening in on the extension in the
file-room; I could hear Kathie damn near faint when you said five
grand.”
“Yes; five thousand dollars for
appraising a collection they’ve been offered ten for, and she only
has a third-interest,” Kathie said, retracting herself into the
chair lately vacated by Gladys Fleming. “If that makes sense,
now …”
“Ah, don’t you get it, Kathleen
Mavourneen?” Ritter asked. “She doesn’t care about the pistols; she
wants Jeff to find out who fixed up that accident for Fleming. You
heard that big, long shaggy-dog story about exactly what happened
and where everybody was supposed to have been at the time. I hope
you got all that recorded; it was all told for a purpose.”
Rand had picked up the outside
phone and was dialing. In a moment, a girl’s voice answered.
“Carter Tipton’s law-office; good
afternoon.”
“Hello, Rheba; is Tip
available?”
“Oh, hello, Jeff. Just a sec;
I’ll see.” She buzzed another phone. “Jeff Rand on the line,” she
announced.
A clear, slightly
Harvard-accented male voice took over.
“Hello, Jeff. Now what sort of
malfeasance have you committed?”
“Nothing, so far—cross my
fingers,” Rand replied. “I just want a little information. Are you
busy? … Okay, I’ll be up directly.”
He replaced the phone and turned
to his disciples.
“Our client,” he said, “wants two
jobs done on one fee. Getting the pistol-collection sold is one
job. Exploring the whys and wherefores of that quote accident
unquote is the other. She has a hunch, and probably nothing much
better, that there’s something sour about the accident. She expects
me to find evidence to that effect while I’m at Rosemont, going
over the collection. I’m not excluding other possibilities, but
I’ll work on that line until and unless I find out differently.
Five thousand should cover both jobs.”
“You think that’s how it is?”
Kathie asked.
“Look, Kathie. I got just as far
in Arithmetic, at school, as you did, and I suspect that Mrs.
Fleming got at least as far as long division, herself. For reasons
I stated, I simply couldn’t have handled that collection business
for anything like a reasonable fee, so I told her five thousand,
thinking that would stop her. When it didn’t, I knew she had
something else in mind, and when she went into all that detail
about the death of her husband, she as good as told me that was
what it was. Now I’m sorry I didn’t say ten thousand; I think she’d
have bought it at that price just as cheerfully. She thinks Lane
Fleming was murdered. Well, on the face of what she told me, so do
I.”
“All right, Professor; expound,”
Ritter said.
“You heard what he was supposed
to have shot himself with,” Rand began. “A Colt-type percussion
revolver. You know what they’re like. And I know enough about Lane
Fleming to know how much experience he had with old arms. I can’t
believe that he’d buy a pistol without carefully examining it, and
I can’t believe that he’d bring that thing home and start working
on it without seeing the caps on the nipples and the charges in the
chambers, if it had been loaded. And if it had been, he would have
first taken off the caps, and then taken it apart and drawn the
charges. And she says he started working on it as soon as he got
home—presumably around five—and then took time out for dinner, and
then went back to work on it, and more than half an hour later,
there was a shot and he was killed.” Rand blew a Bronx cheer. “If
that accident had been the McCoy, it would have happened in the
first five minutes after he started working on that pistol. No, in
the first thirty seconds. And then, when they found him, he had the
revolver in his right hand, and an oily rag in his left. I hope
both of you noticed that little touch.”
“Yeah. When I clean a gat, I
generally have it in my left hand, and clean with my right,” Ritter
said.
“Exactly. And why do you use an
oily rag?” Rand inquired.
Ritter looked at him blankly for
a half-second, then grinned ruefully.
“Damn, I never thought of that,”
he admitted. “Okay, he was bumped off, all right.”
“But you use oily rags on guns,”
Kathie objected. “I’ve seen both of you, often enough.”
“When we’re all through, honey,”
Ritter told her.
“Yes. When he brought home that
revolver, it was in neglected condition,” Rand said. “Either
surface-rusted, or filthy with gummed oil and dirt. Even if Mrs.
Fleming hadn’t mentioned that point, the length of time he spent
cleaning it would justify such an inference. He would have taken it
apart, down to the smallest screw, and cleaned everything
carefully, and then put it together again, and then, when he had
finished, he would have gone over the surface with an oiled rag,
before hanging it on the wall. He would certainly not have
surface-oiled it before removing the charges, if there ever were
any. I assume the revolver he was found holding, presumably the one
with which he was killed, was another one. And I would further
assume that the killer wasn’t particularly familiar with the
subject of firearms, antique, care and maintenance of.”
“And with all the hollering and
whooping and hysterics-throwing, nobody noticed the switch,” Ritter
finished. “Wonder what happened to the one he was really
cleaning.”
“That I may possibly find out,”
Rand said. “The general incompetence with which this murder was
committed gives me plenty of room to hope that it may still be
lying around somewhere.”
“Well, have you thought that it
might just be suicide?” Kathie asked.
“I have, very briefly; I
dismissed the thought, almost at once,” Rand told her. “For two
reasons. One, that if it had been suicide, Mrs. Fleming wouldn’t
want it poked into; she’d be more than willing to let it ride as an
accident. And, two, I doubt if a man who prided himself on his
gun-knowledge, as Fleming did, would want his self-shooting to be
taken for an accident. I’m damn sure I wouldn’t want my friends to
go around saying: ‘What a dope; didn’t know it was loaded!’ I doubt
if he’d even expect people to believe that it had been an
accident.” He shook his head. “No, the only inference I can draw is
that somebody murdered Fleming, and then faked evidence intended to
indicate an accident.” He rose. “I’ll be back, in a little; think
it over, while I’m gone.”
Carter Tipton had his law-office
on the floor above the Tri-State Detective Agency. He handled all
Rand’s not infrequent legal involvements, and Rand did all his
investigating and witness-chasing; annually, they compared books to
see who owed whom how much. Tipton was about five years Rand’s
junior, and had been in the Navy during the war. He was frequently
described as New Belfast’s leading younger attorney and most
eligible bachelor. His dark, conservatively cut clothes fitted him
as though they had been sprayed on, he wore gold-rimmed glasses,
and he was so freshly barbered, manicured, valeted and scrubbed as
to give the impression that he had been born in cellophane and just
unwrapped. He leaned back in his chair and waved his visitor to a
seat.
“Tip, do you know anything about
this Fleming family, out at Rosemont?” Rand began, getting out his
pipe and tobacco.
“The Premix-Foods Flemings?”
Tipton asked. “Yes, a little. Which one of them wants you to frame
what on which other one?”
“That’ll do for a good,
simplified description, to start with,” Rand commented. “Why, my
client is Mrs. Gladys Fleming. As to what she wants. …”
He told the young lawyer about
his recent interview and subsequent conclusions.
“So you see,” he finished, “she
won’t commit herself, even with me. Maybe she thinks I have more
official status, and more obligations to the police, than I have.
Maybe she isn’t sure in her own mind, and wants me to see,
independently, if there’s any smell of something dead in the
woodpile. Or, she may think that having a private detective called
in may throw a scare into somebody. Or maybe she thinks somebody
may be fixing up an accident for her, next, and she wants a
pistol-totin’ gent in the house for a while. Or any combination
thereof. Personally, I deplore these clients who hire you to do one
thing and expect you to do another, but with five grand for
sweetening, I can take them.”
“Yes. You know, I’ve heard rumors
of suicide, but this is the first whiff of murder I’ve caught.” He
hesitated slightly. “I must say, I’m not greatly surprised. Lane
Fleming’s death was very convenient to a number of people. You know
about this Premix Company, don’t you?”
“Vaguely. They manufacture
ready-mixed pancake flour, and ready-mixed ice-cream and pudding
powders, and this dehydrated vegetable soup—pour on hot water,
stir, and serve—don’t they? My colored boy, Buck, got some of the
soup, once, for an experiment. We unanimously voted not to try it
again.”
“They put out quite a line of
such godsends to the neophyte in the kitchen, the popularity of
which is reflected in a steadily rising divorce-rate,” Tipton said.
“They advertise very extensively, including half an hour of
tear-jerking drama on a national hookup during soap-opera time.
Your client, the former Gladys Farrand, was on the air for Premix
for a couple of years; that’s how Lane Fleming first met
her.”
“So you think some irate and
dyspeptic husband went to the source of his woes?” Rand
inquired.
“Well, not exactly. You see,
Premix is only Little Business, as the foods industry goes, but
they have something very sweet. So sweet, in fact, that one of the
really big fellows, National Milling & Packaging, has been
going to rather extreme lengths to effect a merger. Mill-Pack, par
100, is quoted at around 145, and Premix, par 50, is at 75 now, and
Mill-Pack is offering a two-for-one-share exchange, which would be
a little less than four-for-one in value. I might add, for what
it’s worth, that this Stephen Gresham you mentioned is Mill-Pack’s
attorney, negotiator, and general Mr. Fixit; he has been trying to
put over this merger for Mill-Pack.”
“I’ll bear that in mind, too,”
Rand said.
“Naturally, all this is not being
shouted from the housetops,” Tipton continued. “Fact is, it’s a
minor infraction of ethics for me to mention it to you.”
“I’ll file it in the burn-box,”
Rand promised. “What was the matter; didn’t Premix want to
merge?”
“Lane Fleming didn’t. And since
he held fifty-two percent of the common stock himself, try and do
anything about it.”
“Anything short of retiring
Fleming to the graveyard, that is,” Rand amended. “That would do
for a murder-motive, very nicely. … What were Fleming’s objections
to the merger?”
“Mainly sentimental. Premix was
his baby, or, at least, his kid brother. His father started mixing
pancake flour back before the First World War, and Lane Fleming
peddled it off a spring wagon. They worked up a nice little local
trade, and finally a statewide wholesale business. They
incorporated in the early twenties, and then, after the old man
died, Lane Fleming hired an advertising agency to promote his
products, and built up a national distribution, and took on some
sidelines. Then, during the late Mr. Chamberlain’s ‘Peace in our
time,’ he picked up a refugee Czech chemist and foods-expert named
Anton Varcek, who whipped up a lot of new products. So business got
better and better, and they made more money to spend on advertising
to get more money to buy more advertising to make more money, like
Bill Nye’s Puritans digging clams in the winter to get strength to
hoe corn in the summer to get strength to dig clams in the
winter.
“So Premix became a sort of
symbol of achievement to Fleming. Then, he was one of these
old-model paternalistic employers, and he was afraid that if he
relinquished control, a lot of his old retainers would be turned
out to grass. And finally, he was opposed in principle to
concentration of business ownership. He claimed it made business
more vulnerable to government control and eventual
socialization.”
“I’m not sure he didn’t have
something there,” Rand considered. “We get all our corporate eggs
in a few baskets, and they’re that much easier for the
planned-economy boys to grab. … Just who, on the Premix side, was
in favor of this merger?”
“Just about everybody but
Fleming,” Tipton replied. “His two sons-in-law, Fred Dunmore and
Varcek, who are first and second vice presidents. Humphrey Goode,
the company attorney, who doubles as board chairman. All the
directors. All the New York banking crowd who are interested in
Premix. And all the two-share tinymites. I don’t know who inherits
Fleming’s voting interest, but I can find out for you by this time
tomorrow.”
“Do that, Tip, and bill me for
what you think finding out is worth,” Rand said. “It’ll be a novel
reversal of order for you to be billing me for an investigation. …
Now, how about the family, as distinct from the company?”
“Well, there’s your client,
Gladys Fleming. She married Lane Fleming about ten years ago, when
she was twenty-five and he was fifty-five. In spite of the age
difference, I understand it was a fairly happy marriage. Then,
there are two daughters by a previous marriage, Nelda Dunmore and
Geraldine Varcek, and their respective husbands. They all live
together, in a big house at Rosemont. In the company, Dunmore is
Sales, and Varcek is Production. They each have a corner of the
mantle of Lane Fleming in one hand and a dirk in the other. Nelda
and Geraldine hate each other like Greeks and Trojans. Nelda is the
nymphomaniac sister, and Geraldine is the dipsomaniac. From time to
time, temporary alliances get formed, mainly against Gladys; all of
them resent the way she married herself into a third-interest in
the estate. You’re going to have yourself a nice, pleasant little
stay in the country.”
“I’m looking forward to it.” Rand
grimaced. “You mentioned suicide rumors. Such as, and who’s been
spreading them?”
“Oh, they are the usual bodyless
voices that float about,” Tipton told him. “Emanating, I suspect,
from sources interested in shaking out the less sophisticated small
shareholders before the merger. The story is always approximately
the same: That Lane Fleming saw his company drifting reefward, was
unwilling to survive the shipwreck, and performed seppuku. The
family are supposed to have faked up the accident afterward. I
dismiss the whole thing as a rather less than subtle bit of
market-manipulation chicanery.”
“Or a smoke screen, to cover the
defects in camouflaging a murder as an accident,” Rand added.
Tipton nodded. “That could be so,
too,” he agreed. “Say somebody dislikes the looks of that accident,
and starts investigating. Then he runs into all this miasma of
suicide rumors, and promptly shrugs the whole thing off. Fleming
killed himself, and the family made a few alterations and are
passing it off as an accident. The families of suicides have been
known to do that.”