The Art of Being Right E-Book

Arthur Schopenhauer

• Herausgeber: Bauer World Press
• Kategorie: Bildung
• Sprache: Englisch
• Veröffentlichungsjahr: 2024

Beschreibung

The Art of Being Right: 38 Ways to Win an Argument by Arthur Schopenhauer (Bauer World Press)

Unlock the secrets to mastering the art of argument with Arthur Schopenhauer's The Art of Being Right: 38 Ways to Win an Argument. This classic guide reveals powerful strategies for debating and persuading others, offering timeless insights into the tactics and psychological maneuvers that can turn the tide of any discussion. Whether you're a philosopher, debater, or just looking to improve your communication skills, Schopenhauer's techniques will equip you with the tools to argue effectively and convincingly.

Leseprobe

Bauer World Press

the art of being right

38 Ways to Win an Argument

Written by

Arthur Schopenhauer

Bauer World Press

Bauer World Press gladly makes available a plenitude of literary treasures hailing from around the globe. In each accessible volume, Bauer upholds its dedication to erudition by furnishing only the most authentic and original texts. These include introductions by venerated authorities, elucidative notes, and many other features to encourage further exploration, should you so wish. By offering the long-forgotten writings of distant epochs, as well as celebrated literary masterpieces, Bauer World Press endeavours not only to enhance the pleasure of reading today, but to revivify the voices of antiquity; lest their wisdom be lost on us forever. Unwavering commitment to research and accuracy spans the breadth of our works, each edition augmented with commentary and context.

In hoc signo vinces.

Bauer World Press is a division of The Bauer Company.

Bauer World Press furthers the Company's objective of excellence in historical research, education, and knowledge by publishing digital and paperback content worldwide.

The moral rights of the authors have been asserted.

First Published as a Bauer World Press eBook 2024

All original additions are copyright 2024 by Bauer World Press and may not be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, by any form or any means, without the prior permission in writing of Bauer World Press, or as expressly permitted by law, by license or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be directed to the address below.

All rights reserved.

[email protected]

Published in the United States of America by Bauer World Press

the art of being right

38 Ways to Win an Argument

Rule 1

the extension

This consists in carrying your opponent’s proposition beyond its natural limits; in giving it as general a signification and as wide a sense as possible, so as to exaggerate it; and, on the other hand, in giving your own proposition as restricted a sense and as narrow limits as you can, because the more general a statement becomes, the more numerous are the objections to which it is open. The defence consists in an accurate statement of the point or essential question at issue.

Example 1. — I asserted that the English were supreme in drama. My Opponent attempted to give an instance to the contrary, and replied that it was a well-known fact that in music, and consequently in opera, they could do nothing at all. I repelled the attack by reminding him that music was not included in dramatic art, which covered tragedy and comedy alone. This he knew very well. What he had done was to try to generalise my proposition, so that it would apply to all theatrical representations, and, consequently, to opera and then to music, in order to make certain of defeating me. Contrarily, we may save our proposition by reducing it within narrower limits than we had first intended, if our way of expressing it favours this expedient.

Example 2. — A. declares that the Peace of 1814 gave back their independence to all the German towns of the Hanseatic League. B. gives an instance to the contrary by reciting the fact that Dantzig, which received its independence from Buonaparte, lost it by that Peace. A. saves himself thus: “T said ‘all German towns,’ and Dantzig was in Poland.”

This trick was mentioned by Aristotle in the Topica (bk. viii., cc. 11, 12).

Example 3. — Lamarck, in his Philosophie Zoologique (vol. i., ), states that the polype has no feeling, because it has no nerves. It is certain, however, that it has some sort of perception; for it advances towards light by moving in an ingenious fashion from branch to branch, and it seizes its prey. Hence it has been assumed that its nervous system is spread over the whole of its body in equal measure, as though it were blended with it; for it is obvious that the polype possesses some faculty of perception without having any separate organs of sense. Since this assumption refutes Lamarck’s position, he argues thus: “In that case all parts of its body must be capable of every kind of feeling, and also of motion, of will, of thought. The polype would have all the organs of the most perfect animal in every point of its body; every point could see, smell, taste, hear, and so on; nay, it could think, judge, and draw conclusions; every particle of its body would be a perfect animal, and it would stand higher than man, as every part of it would possess all the faculties which man possesses only in the whole of him. Further, there would be no reason for not extending what is true of the polype to all monads, the most imperfect of all creatures, and ultimately to the plants, which are also alive, etc., etc.” By using dialectical tricks of this kind a writer betrays that he is secretly conscious of being in the wrong. Because it was said that the creature’s whole body is sensitive to light, and is therefore possessed of nerves, he makes out that its whole body is capable of thought.