Mental Science
Mental ScienceI The Hidden PowerII The Perversion of TruthIII The “I Am”IV Affirmative PowerV SubmissionVI CompletenessVIIThe Principle of GuidanceVIII Desire as the Motive PowerIX Touching LightlyX Present TruthXI YourselfXII Religious OpinionsXIII A Lesson from BrowningXIV The Spirit of OpulenceXV BeautyXVI Separation and UnityXVII ExternalisationXVIII Entering into the Spirit of ItXIX The Bible and the New ThoughtXX Jachin and BoazXXI HephzibahXXII Mind and HandXXIII The Central ControlXXIV What Is Higher Thought?XXV FragmentsCopyright
Mental Science
T. Troward
I The Hidden Power
To realise fully how much of our present daily life consists
in symbols is to find the answer to the old, old question, What is
Truth? and in the degree in which we begin to recognise this we
begin to approach Truth. The realisation of Truth consists in the
ability to translate symbols, whether natural or conventional, into
their equivalents; and the root of all the errors of mankind
consists in the inability to do this, and in maintaining that the
symbol has nothing behind it. The great duty incumbent on all who
have attained to this knowledge is to impress upon their fellow men
that there is aninner sideto
things, and that until thisinnerside is known, the things themselves are not
known.There is an inner and an outer side to everything; and the
quality of the superficial mind which causes it to fail in the
attainment of Truth is its willingness to rest content with the
outside only. So long as this is the case it is impossible for a
man to grasp the import of his own relation to the universal, and
it is this relation which constitutes all that is signified by the
word "Truth." So long as a man fixes his attention only on the
superficial it is impossible for him to make any progress in
knowledge. He is denying that principle of "Growth" which is the
root of all life, whether spiritual intellectual, or material, for
he does not stop to reflect that all which he sees as the outer
side of things can result only from some germinal principle hidden
deep in the centre of their being.Expansion from the centre by growth according to a necessary
order of sequence, this is the Law of Life of which the whole
universe is the outcome, alike in the one great solidarity of
cosmic being, as in the separate individualities of its minutest
organisms. This great principle is the key to the whole riddle of
Life, upon whatever plane we contemplate it; and without this key
the door from the outer to the inner side of things can never be
opened. It is therefore the duty of all to whom this door has, at
least in some measure, been opened, to endeavour to acquaint others
with the fact that there is an inner side to things, and that life
becomes truer and fuller in proportion as we penetrate to it and
make our estimates of all things according to what becomes visible
from this interior point of view.In the widest sense everything is a symbol of that which
constitutes its inner being, and all Nature is a gallery of arcana
revealing great truths to those who can decipher them. But there is
a more precise sense in which our current life is based upon
symbols in regard to the most important subjects that can occupy
our thoughts: the symbols by which we strive to represent the
nature and being of God, and the manner in which the life of man is
related to the Divine life. The whole character of a man's life
results from what he really believes on this subject: not his
formal statement of belief in a particular creed, but what he
realises as the stage which his mind has actually attained in
regard to it.Has a man's mind only reached the point at which he thinks it
is impossible to know anything about God, or to make any use of the
knowledge if he had it? Then his whole interior world is in the
condition of confusion, which must necessarily exist where no
spirit of order has yet begun to move upon the chaos in which are,
indeed, the elements of being, but all disordered and neutralising
one another. Has he advanced a step further, and realised that
there is a ruling and an ordering power, but beyond this is
ignorant of its nature? Then the unknown stands to him for the
terrific, and, amid a tumult of fears and distresses that deprive
him of all strength to advance, he spends his life in the endeavour
to propitiate this power as something naturally adverse to him,
instead of knowing that it is the very centre of his own life and
being.And so on through every degree, from the lowest depths of
ignorance to the greatest heights of intelligence, a man's life
must always be the exact reflection of that particular stage which
he has reached in the perception of the divine nature and of his
own relation to it; and as we approach the full perception of
Truth, so the life-principle within us expands, the old bonds and
limitations which had no existence in reality fall off from us, and
we enter into regions of light, liberty, and power, of which we had
previously no conception. It is impossible, therefore, to
overestimate the importance of being able to realise the
symbolfora symbol, and being
able to penetrate to the inner substance which it represents. Life
itself is to be realised only by the conscious experience of its
livingness in ourselves, and it is the endeavour to translate these
experiences into terms which shall suggest a corresponding idea to
others that gives rise to all symbolism.The nearer those we address have approached to the actual
experience, the more transparent the symbol becomes; and the
further they are from such experience the thicker is the veil; and
our whole progress consists in the fuller and fuller translation of
the symbols into clearer and clearer statements of that for which
they stand. But the first step, without which all succeeding ones
must remain impossible, is to convince people that symbolsaresymbols, and not the very Truth
itself. And the difficulty consists in this, that if the symbolism
is in any degree adequate it must, in some measure, represent the
form of Truth, just as the modelling of a drapery suggests the form
of the figure beneath. They have a certain consciousness that
somehow they are in the presence of Truth; and this leads people to
resent any removal of those folds of drapery which have hitherto
conveyed this idea to their minds.There is sufficient indication of the inner Truth in the
outward form to afford an excuse for the timorous, and those who
have not sufficient mental energy to think for themselves, to cry
out that finality has already been attained, and that any further
search into the matter must end in the destruction of Truth. But in
raising such an outcry they betray their ignorance of the very
nature of Truth, which is that it can never be destroyed: the very
fact that Truth is Truth makes this impossible. And again they
exhibit their ignorance of the first principle of Life—namely, the
Law of Growth, which throughout the universe perpetually pushes
forward into more and more vivid forms of expression, having
expansion everywhere and finality nowhere.Such ignorant objections need not, therefore, alarm us; and
we should endeavour to show those who make them that what they fear
is the only natural order of the Divine Life, which is "over all,
and through all, and in all." But we must do this gently, and not
by forcibly thrusting upon them the object of their terror, and so
repelling them from all study of the subject. We should endeavour
gradually to lead them to see that there is something interior to
what they have hitherto held to be ultimate Truth, and to realise
that the sensation of emptiness and dissatisfaction, which from
time to time will persist in making itself felt in their hearts, is
nothing else than the pressing forward of the spirit within to
declare that inner side of things which alone can satisfactorily
account for what we observe on the exterior, and without the
knowledge of which we can never perceive the true nature of our
inheritance in the Universal Life which is the Life
Everlasting.IIWhat, then, is this central principle which is at the root of
all things? It is Life. But not life as we recognise it in
particular forms of manifestation; it is something more interior
and concentrated than that. It is that "unity of the spirit"
whichisunity, simply because
it has not yet passed into diversity. Perhaps this is not an easy
idea to grasp, but it is the root of all scientific conception of
spirit; for without it there is no common principle to which we can
refer the innumerable forms of manifestation that spirit
assumes.It is the conception of Life as the sum-total of all its
undistributed powers, being as yet none of these in particular, but
all of them in potentiality. This is, no doubt, a highly abstract
idea, but it is essentially that of the centre from which growth
takes place by expansion in every direction. This is that last
residuum which defies all our powers of analysis. This is truly
"the unknowable," not in the sense of the unthinkable but of the
unanalysable. It is the subject of perception, not of knowledge, if
by knowledge we mean that faculty which estimates therelationsbetween things, because here
we have passed beyond any questions of relations, and are face to
face with the absolute.This innermost of all is absolute Spirit. It is Life as yet
not differentiated into any specific mode; it is the universal Life
which pervades all things and is at the heart of all
appearances.To come into the knowledge of this is to come into the secret
of power, and to enter into the secret place of Living Spirit. Is
it illogical first to call this the unknowable, and then to speak
of coming into the knowledge of it? Perhaps so; but no less a
writer than St. Paul has set the example; for does he not speak of
the final result of all searchings into the heights and depths and
lengths and breadths of the inner side of things as being, to
attain the knowledge of that Love which passeth knowledge. If he is
thus boldly illogical in phrase, though not in fact, may we not
also speak of knowing "the unknowable"? We may, for this knowledge
is the root of all other knowledge.The presence of this undifferentiated universal life-power is
the final axiomatic fact to which all our analysis must ultimately
conduct us. On whatever plane we make our analysis it must always
abut upon pure essence, pure energy, pure being; that which knows
itself and recognises itself, but which cannot dissect itself
because it is not built up of parts, but is ultimately integral: it
is pure Unity. But analysis which does not lead to synthesis is
merely destructive: it is the child wantonly pulling the flower to
pieces and throwing away the fragments; not the botanist, also
pulling the flower to pieces, but building up in his mind from
those carefully studied fragments a vast synthesis of the
constructive power of Nature, embracing the laws of the formation
of all flower-forms. The value of analysis is to lead us to the
original starting-point of that which we analyse, and so to teach
us the laws by which its final form springs from this
centre.Knowing the law of its construction, we turn our analysis
into a synthesis, and we thus gain a power of building up which
must always be beyond the reach of those who regard "the
unknowable" as one with "not-being."Thisidea of the unknowable is the root
of all materialism; and yet no scientific man, however
materialistic his proclivities, treats the unanalysable residuum
thus when he meets it in the experiments of his laboratory. On the
contrary, he makes this final unanalysable fact the basis of his
synthesis. He finds that in the last resort it is energy of some
kind, whether as heat or as motion; but he does not throw up his
scientific pursuits because he cannot analyse it further. He adopts
the precisely opposite course, and realises that the conservation
of energy, its indestructibility, and the impossibility of adding
to or detracting from the sum-total of energy in the world, is the
one solid and unchanging fact on which alone the edifice of
physical science can be built up. He bases all his knowledge upon
his knowledge of "the unknowable." And rightly so, for if he could
analyse this energy into yet further factors, then the same problem
of "the unknowable" would meet him still. All our progress consists
in continually pushing the unknowable, in the sense of the
unanalysable residuum, a step further back; but that there should
be no ultimate unanalysable residuum anywhere is an inconceivable
idea.In thus realising the undifferentiated unity of Living Spirit
as the central fact of any system, whether the system of the entire
universe or of a single organism, we are therefore following a
strictly scientific method. We pursue our analysis until it
necessarily leads us to this final fact, and then we accept this
fact as the basis of our synthesis. The Science of Spirit is thus
not one whit less scientific than the Science of Matter; and,
moreover, it starts from the same initial fact, the fact of a
living energy which defies definition or explanation, wherever we
find it; but it differs from the science of matter in that it
contemplates this energy under an aspect of responsive intelligence
which does not fall within the scope of physical science, as such.
The Science of Spirit and the Science of Matter are not opposed.
They are complementaries, and neither is fully comprehensible
without some knowledge of the other; and, being really but two
portions of one whole, they insensibly shade off into each other in
a border-land where no arbitrary line can be drawn between them.
Science studied in a truly scientific spirit, following out its own
deductions unflinchingly to their legitimate conclusions, will
always reveal the twofold aspect of things, the inner and the
outer; and it is only a truncated and maimed science that refuses
to recognise both.The study of the material world is not Materialism, if it be
allowed to progress to its legitimate issue. Materialism is that
limited view of the universe which will not admit the existence of
anything but mechanical effects of mechanical causes, and a system
which recognises no higher power than the physical forces of nature
must logically result in having no higher ultimate appeal than to
physical force or to fraud as its alternative. I speak, of course,
of the tendency of the system, not of the morality of individuals,
who are often very far in advance of the systems they profess. But
as we would avoid the propagation of a mode of thought whose
effects history shows only too plainly, whether in the Italy of the
Borgias, or the France of the First Revolution, or the Commune of
the Franco-Prussian War, we should set ourselves to study that
inner and spiritual aspect of things which is the basis of a system
whose logical results are truth and love instead of perfidy and
violence.Some of us, doubtless, have often wondered why the Heavenly
Jerusalem is described in the Book of Revelations as a cube; "the
length and the breadth and the height of it are equal." This is
because the cube is the figure of perfect stability, and thus
represents Truth, which can never be overthrown. Turn it on what
side you will, it still remains the perfect cube, always standing
upright; you cannot upset it. This figure, then, represents the
manifestation in concrete solidity of that central life-giving
energy, which is not itself any one plane but generates all planes,
the planes of the above and of the below and of all four sides. But
it is at the same time a city, a place of habitation; and this is
because that which is "the within" is Living Spirit, which has its
dwelling there.As one plane of the cube implies all the other planes and
also "the within," so any plane of manifestation implies the others
and also that "within" which generates them all. Now, if we would
make any progress in the spiritual side of science—andeverydepartment of science has its
spiritual side—we must always keep our minds fixed upon this
"innermost within" which contains the potential of all outward
manifestation, the "fourth dimension" which generates the cube; and
our common forms of speech show how intuitively we do this. We
speak of the spirit in which an act is done, of entering into the
spirit of a game, of the spirit of the time, and so on. Everywhere
our intuition points out the spirit as the true essence of things;
and it is only when we commence arguing about them from without,
instead of from within, that our true perception of their nature is
lost.The scientific study of spirit consists in following up
intelligently and according to definite method the same principle
that now only flashes upon us at intervals fitfully and vaguely.
When we once realise that this universal and unlimited power of
spirit is at the root of all things and of ourselves also, then we
have obtained the key to the whole position; and, however far we
may carry our studies in spiritual science, we shall nowhere find
anything else but particular developments of this one universal
principle. "The Kingdom of Heaven iswithinyou."IIII have laid stress on the fact that the "innermost within" of
all things is living Spirit, and that the Science of Spirit is
distinguished from the Science of Matter in that it contemplates
Energy under an aspect of responsive intelligence which does not
fall within the scope of physical science, as such. These are the
two great points to lay hold of if we would retain a clear idea of
Spiritual Science, and not be misled by arguments drawn from the
physical side of Science only—the livingness of the originating
principle which is at the heart of all things, and its intelligent
and responsive nature. Its livingness is patent to our observation,
at any rate from the point where we recognise it in the vegetable
kingdom; but its intelligence and responsiveness are not, perhaps,
at once so obvious. Nevertheless, a little thought will soon lead
us to recognise this also.No one can deny that there is an intelligent order throughout
all nature, for it requires the highest intelligence of our most
highly-trained minds to follow the steps of this universal
intelligence which is always in advance of them. The more deeply we
investigate the world we live in, the more clear it must become to
us that all our science is the translation into words or numerical
symbols of that order which already exists. If the clear statement
of this existing order is the highest that the human intellect can
reach, this surely argues a corresponding intelligence in the power
which gives rise to this great sequence of order and interrelation,
so as to constitute one harmonious whole. Now, unless we fall back
on the idea of a workman working upon material external to
himself—in which case we have to explain the phenomenon of the
workman—the only conception we can form of this power is that it is
the Living Spirit inherent in the heart of every atom, giving it
outward form and definition, and becoming in it those intrinsic
polarities which constitute its characteristic nature.There is no random work here. Every attraction and repulsion
acts with its proper force collecting the atoms into molecules, the
molecules into tissues, the tissues into organs, and the organs
into individuals. At each stage of the progress we get the sum of
the intelligent forces which operate in the constituent
parts,plusa higher degree of
intelligence which we may regard as the collective intelligence
superior to that of the mere sum-total of the parts, something
which belongs to the individualas a
whole, and not to the parts as such. These are
facts which can be amply proved from physical science; and they
also supply a great law in spiritual science, which is that in any
collective body the intelligence of the whole is superior to that
of the sum of the parts.Spirit is at the root of all things, and thoughtful
observation shows that its operation is guided by unfailing
intelligence which adapts means to ends, and harmonises the entire
universe of manifested being in those wonderful ways which physical
science renders clearer every day; and this intelligence must be in
the generating spirit itself, because there is no other source from
which it could proceed. On these grounds, therefore, we may
distinctly affirm that Spirit is intelligent, and that whatever it
does is done by the intelligent adaptation of means to
ends.But Spirit is also responsive. And here we have to fall back
upon the law above stated, that the mere sum of the intelligence of
Spirit in lower degrees of manifestation is not equal to the
intelligence of the complexwhole, as a whole. This is a radical law which we cannot impress
upon our minds too deeply. The degree of spiritual intelligence is
marked by the wholeness of the organism through which it finds
expression; and therefore the more highly organised being has a
degree of spirit which is superior to, and consequently capable of
exercising control over, all lower or less fully-integrated degrees
of spirit; and this being so, we can now begin to see why the
spirit that is the "innermost within" of all things is responsive
as well as intelligent.Being intelligent, itknows, and spirit being ultimately all there is, that which it
knows is itself. Hence it is that power which recognises itself;
and accordingly the lower powers of it recognise its higher powers,
and by the law of attraction they are bound to respond to the
higher degrees of themselves. On this general principle, therefore,
spirit, under whatever exterior revealed, is necessarily
intelligent and responsive. But intelligence and responsiveness
imply personality; and we may therefore now advance a step further
and argue thatallspirit
contains the elements of personality, even though, in any
particular instance, it may not yet be expressed as that individual
personality which we find in ourselves.In short, spirit is always personal in its nature, even when
it has not yet attained to that degree of synthesis which is
sufficient to render it personal in manifestation. In ourselves the
synthesis has proceeded far enough to reach that degree, and
therefore we recognise ourselves as the manifestation of
personality. The human kingdom is the kingdom of the manifestation
of that personality, which is of the essence of spiritual substance
on every plane. Or, to put the whole argument in a simpler form, we
may say that our own personality must necessarily have had its
origin in that which is personal, on the principle that you cannot
get more out of a bag than it contains.In ourselves, therefore, we find that more perfect synthesis
of the spirit into manifested personality which is wanting in the
lower kingdoms of nature, and, accordingly, since spirit is
necessarily that which knows itself and must, therefore, recognise
its own degrees in its various modes, the spirit in all degrees
below that of human personality is bound to respond to itself in
that superior degree which constitutes human individuality; and
this is the basis of the power of human thought to externalise
itself in infinite forms of its own ordering.But if the subordination of the lower degrees of spirit to
the higher is one of the fundamental laws which lie at the bottom
of the creative power of thought, there is another equally
fundamental law which places a salutary restraint upon the abuse of
that power. It is the law that we can command the powers of the
universal for our own purposes only in proportion as we first
realise and obey their generic character. We can employ water for
any purpose which does not require it to run up-hill, and we can
utilise electricity for any purpose that does not require it to
pass from a lower to a higher potential.So with that universal power which we call the Spirit. It has
an inherent generic character with which we must comply if we would
employ it for our specific purposes, and this character is summed
up in the one word "goodness." The Spirit is Life, hence its
generic tendency must always be lifeward or to the increase of the
livingness of every individual. And since it is universal it can
have no particular interests to serve, and therefore its action
must always be equally for the benefit of all. This is the generic
character of spirit; and just as water, or electricity, or any
other of the physical forces of the universe, will not work
contrary to their generic character, so Spirit will not work
contrary to its generic character.The inference is obvious. If we would use Spirit we must
follow the law of the Spirit which is "Goodness." This is the only
limitation. If our originating intention is good, we may employ the
spiritual power for what purpose we will. And how is "goodness" to
be defined? Simply by the child's definition that what is bad is
not good, and that what is good is not bad; we all know the
difference between bad and good instinctively. If we will conform
to this principle of obedience to the generic law of the Spirit,
all that remains is for us to study the law of the proportion which
exists between the more and less fully integrated modes of Spirit,
and then bring our knowledge to bear with
determination.IVThe law of spirit, to which our investigation has now led us,
is of the very widest scope. We have followed it up from the
conception of the intelligence of spirit, subsisting in the initial
atoms, to the aggregation of this intelligence as the conscious
identity of the individual. But there is no reason why this law
should cease to operate at this point, or at any point short of the
whole. The test of the soundness of any principle is that it can
operate as effectively on a large scale as on a small one, that
though the nature of its field is determined by the nature of the
principle itself, the extent of its field is unlimited. If,
therefore, we continue to follow up the law we have been
considering, it leads us to the conception of a unit of
intelligence as far superior to that of the individual man as the
unity of his individual intelligence is superior to that of the
intelligence of any single atom of his body; and thus we may
conceive of a collective individuality representing the spiritual
character of any aggregate of men, the inhabitants of a city, a
district, a country, or of the entire world.Nor need the process stop here. On the same principle there
would be a superior collective individuality for the humanity of
the entire solar system, and finally we reach the conception of a
supreme intelligence bringing together in itself the collective
individualities of all the systems in the universe. This is by no
means a merely fanciful notion. We find it as the law by which our
own conscious individuality is constituted; and we find the
analogous principle working universally on the physical plane. It
is known to physical science as the "law of inverse squares," by
which the forces of reciprocal attraction or repulsion, as the case
may be, are not merely equivalent to the sum of the forces emitted
by the two bodies concerned, but are equivalent to these two forces
multiplied together and divided by the square of the distance
between them, so that the resultant power continually rises in a
rapidly-increasing ratio as the two reciprocally exciting bodies
approach one another.Since this law is so universal throughout physical nature,
the doctrine of continuity affords every ground for supposing that
its analogue holds good in respect of spiritual nature. We must
never lose sight of the old-world saying that "a truth on one plane
is a truth on all." If a principle exists at all it exists
universally. We must not allow ourselves to be misled by
appearances; we must remember that the perceptible results of the
working of any principle consist of two factors—the principle
itself or the active factor, and the subject-matter on which it
acts or the passive factor; and that while the former is
invariable, the latter is variable, and that the operation of the
same invariable upon different variables must necessarily produce a
variety of results. This at once becomes evident if we state it
mathematically; for example,a,borc, multiplied byxgive respectively the resultsax,bx,cx, which differ
materially from one another, though the factorxalways remains the same.This law of the generation of power by attraction applies on
the spiritual as well as on the physical plane, and acts with the
same mathematical precision on both; and thus the human
individuality consists, not in the mere aggregation of its parts,
whether spiritual or corporeal, but in theunityof power resulting from the
intimate association into which those parts enter with one another,
which unity, according to this law of the generation of power by
attraction, is infinitely superior, both in intelligence and power,
to any less fully integrated mode of spirit. Thus a natural
principle, common alike to physical and spiritual law, fully
accounts for all claims that have ever been made for the creative
power of our thought over all things that come within the circle of
our own particular life. Thus it is that each man is the centre of
his own universe, and has the power, by directing his own thought,
to control all things therein.But, as I have said above, there is no reason why this
principle should not be recognised as expanding from the individual
until it embraces the entire universe. Each man, as the centre of
his own world, is himself centred in a higher system in which he is
only one of innumerable similar atoms, and this system again in a
higher until we reach the supreme centre of all things;
intelligence and power increase from centre to centre in a ratio
rising with inconceivable rapidity, according to the law we are now
investigating, until they culminate in illimitable intelligence and
power commensurate with All-Being.