Note Book of an English Opium-Eater
Note Book of an English Opium-EaterTHREE MEMORABLE MURDERS.THE TRUE RELATIONS OF THE BIBLE TO MERELY HUMAN SCIENCE.SCHLOSSER'S LITERARY HISTORY OF THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY.FOX AND BURKE.JUNIUSTHE ANTIGONE OF SOPHOCLES, AS REPRESENTED ON THE EDINBURGH STAGE.THE MARQUESS WELLESLEY. [1]MILTON VERSUS SOUTHEY AND LANDOR.FALSIFICATION OF ENGLISH HISTORY.A PERIPATETIC PHILOSOPHER.ON SUICIDE.SUPERFICIAL KNOWLEDGE.ENGLISH DICTIONARIES.DRYDEN'S HEXASTICH.POPE'S RETORT UPON ADDISON.Copyright
Note Book of an English Opium-Eater
Thomas De Quincey
THREE MEMORABLE MURDERS.
A SEQUEL TO 'MURDER CONSIDERED AS ONE OF THE FINE
ARTS.' [1]It is impossible to conciliate readers of so saturnine
and gloomy a class, that they cannot enter with genial sympathy
into any gaiety whatever, but, least of all, when the gaiety
trespasses a little into the province of the extravagant. In such a
case, not to sympathize is not to understand; and the playfulness,
which is not relished, becomes flat and insipid, or absolutely
without meaning. Fortunately, after all such churls have withdrawn
from my audience in high displeasure, there remains a large
majority who are loud in acknowledging the amusement which they
have derived from a former paper of mine, 'On Murder considered as
one of the Fine Arts;' at the same time proving the sincerity of
their praise by one hesitating expression of censure. Repeatedly
they have suggested to me, that perhaps the extravagance, though
clearly intentional, and forming one element in the general gaiety
of the conception, went too far. I am not myself of that opinion;
and I beg to remind these friendly censors, that it is amongst the
direct purposes and efforts of thisbagatelleto graze the brink of horror,
and of all that would in actual realization be most repulsive. The
very excess of the extravagance, in fact, by suggesting to the
reader continually the mere aeriality of the entire speculation,
furnishes the surest means of disenchanting him from the horror
which might else gather upon his feelings. Let me remind such
objectors, once for all, of Dean Swift's proposal for turning to
account the supernumerary infants of the three kingdoms, which, in
those days, both at Dublin and at London, were provided for in
foundling hospitals, by cooking and eating them. This was an
extravaganza, though really bolder and more coarsely practical than
mine, which did not provoke any reproaches even to a dignitary of
the supreme Irish church; its own monstrosity was its excuse; mere
extravagance was felt to license and accredit the littlejeu d'esprit, precisely as the blank
impossibilities of Lilliput, of Laputa, of the Yahoos, &c., had
licensed those. If, therefore, any man thinks it worth his while to
tilt against so mere a foam-bubble of gaiety as this lecture on the
aesthetics of murder, I shelter myself for the moment under the
Telamonian shield of the Dean. But, in reality, my own little paper
may plead a privileged excuse for its extravagance, such as is
altogether wanting to the Dean's. Nobody can pretend, for a moment,
on behalf of the Dean, that there is any ordinary and natural
tendency in human thoughts, which could ever turn to infants as
articles of diet; under any conceivable circumstances, this would
be felt as the most aggravated form of cannibalism—cannibalism
applying itself to the most defenceless part of the species. But,
on the other hand, the tendency to a critical or aesthetic
valuation of fires and murders is universal. If you are summoned to
the spectacle of a great fire, undoubtedly the first impulse is—to
assist in putting it out. But that field of exertion is very
limited, and is soon filled by regular professional people, trained
and equipped for the service. In the case of a fire which is
operating uponprivateproperty,
pity for a neighbor's calamity checks us at first in treating the
affair as a scenic spectacle. But perhaps the fire may be confined
to public buildings. And in any case, after we have paid our
tribute of regret to the affair, considered as a calamity,
inevitably, and without restraint, we go on to consider it as a
stage spectacle. Exclamations of—How grand! How magnificent! arise
in a sort of rapture from the crowd. For instance, when Drury Lane
was burned down in the first decennium of this century, the falling
in of the roof was signalized by a mimic suicide of the protecting
Apollo that surmounted and crested the centre of this roof. The god
was stationary with his lyre, and seemed looking down upon the
fiery ruins that were so rapidly approaching him. Suddenly the
supporting timbers below him gave way; a convulsive heave of the
billowing flames seemed for a moment to raise the statue; and then,
as if on some impulse of despair, the presiding deity appeared not
to fall, but to throw himself into the fiery deluge, for he went
down head foremost; and in all respects, the descent had the air of
a voluntary act. What followed? From every one of the bridges over
the river, and from other open areas which commanded the spectacle,
there arose a sustained uproar of admiration and sympathy. Some few
years before this event, a prodigious fire occurred at Liverpool;
theGoree, a vast pile of
warehouses close to one of the docks, was burned to the ground. The
huge edifice, eight or nine stories high, and laden with most
combustible goods, many thousand bales of cotton, wheat and oats in
thousands of quarters, tar, turpentine, rum, gunpowder, &c.,
continued through many hours of darkness to feed this tremendous
fire. To aggravate the calamity, it blew a regular gale of wind;
luckily for the shipping, it blew inland, that is, to the east; and
all the way down to Warrington, eighteen miles distant to the
eastward, the whole air was illuminated by flakes of cotton, often
saturated with rum, and by what seemed absolute worlds of blazing
sparks, that lighted up all the upper chambers of the air. All the
cattle lying abroad in the fields through a breadth of eighteen
miles, were thrown into terror and agitation. Men, of course, read
in this hurrying overhead of scintillating and blazing vortices,
the annunciation of some gigantic calamity going on in Liverpool;
and the lamentation on that account was universal. But that mood of
public sympathy did not at all interfere to suppress or even to
check the momentary bursts of rapturous admiration, as this arrowy
sleet of many-colored fire rode on the wings of hurricane,
alternately through open depths of air, or through dark clouds
overhead.Precisely the same treatment is applied to murders.
After the first tribute of sorrow to those who have perished, but,
at all events, after the personal interests have been tranquillized
by time, inevitably the scenical features (what aesthetically may
be called the comparativeadvantages) of the several murders are reviewed and valued. One murder
is compared with another; and the circumstances of superiority, as,
for example, in the incidence and effects of surprise, of mystery,
&c., are collated and appraised. I, therefore, formyextravagance, claim an inevitable
and perpetual ground in the spontaneous tendencies of the human
mind when left to itself. But no one will pretend that any
corresponding plea can be advanced on behalf of
Swift.In this important distinction between myself and the Dean,
lies one reason which prompted the present writing. A second
purpose of this paper is, to make the reader acquainted
circumstantially with three memorable cases of murder, which long
ago the voice of amateurs has crowned with laurel, but especially
with the two earliest of the three, viz., the immortal Williams'
murders of 1812. The act and the actor are each separately in the
highest degree interesting; and, as forty-two years have elapsed
since 1812, it cannot be supposed that either is known
circumstantially to the men of the current generation.Never, throughout the annals of universal Christendom,
has there indeed been any act of one solitary insulated individual,
armed with power so appalling over the hearts of men, as that
exterminating murder, by which, during the winter of 1812, John
Williams in one hour, smote two houses with emptiness, exterminated
all but two entire households, and asserted his own supremacy above
all the children of Cain. It would be absolutely impossible
adequately to describe the frenzy of feelings which, throughout the
next fortnight, mastered the popular heart; the mere delirium of
indignant horror in some, the mere delirium of panic in others. For
twelve succeeding days, under some groundless notion that the
unknown murderer had quitted London, the panic which had convulsed
the mighty metropolis diffused itself all over the island. I was
myself at that time nearly three hundred miles from London; but
there, and everywhere, the panic was indescribable. One lady, my
next neighbor, whom personally I knew, living at the moment, during
the absence of her husband, with a few servants in a very solitary
house, never rested until she had placed eighteen doors (so she
told me, and, indeed, satisfied me by ocular proof), each secured
by ponderous bolts, and bars, and chains, between her own bedroom
and any intruder of human build. To reach her, even in her
drawing-room, was like going, as a flag of truce, into a
beleaguered fortress; at every sixth step one was stopped by a sort
of portcullis. The panic was not confined to the rich; women in the
humblest ranks more than once died upon the spot, from the shock
attending some suspicious attempts at intrusion upon the part of
vagrants, meditating probably nothing worse than a robbery, but
whom the poor women, misled by the London newspapers, had fancied
to be the dreadful London murderer. Meantime, this solitary artist,
that rested in the centre of London, self-supported by his own
conscious grandeur, as a domestic Attila, or 'scourge of God;' this
man, that walked in darkness, and relied upon murder (as afterwards
transpired) for bread, for clothes, for promotion in life, was
silently preparing an effectual answer to the public journals; and
on the twelfth day after his inaugural murder, he advertised his
presence in London, and published to all men the absurdity of
ascribing tohimany ruralizing
propensities, by striking a second blow, and accomplishing a second
family extermination. Somewhat lightened was theprovincialpanic by this proof that the
murderer had not condescended to sneak into the country, or to
abandon for a moment, under any motive of caution or fear, the
great metropolitancastra stativaof gigantic crime, seated for ever on the Thames. In fact,
the great artist disdained a provincial reputation; and he must
have felt, as a case of ludicrous disproportion, the contrast
between a country town or village, on the one hand, and, on the
other, a work more lasting than brass—a [Greek:chtaema es aei]—a murder such in
quality as any murder thathewould condescend to own for a work turned out from his
ownstudio.Coleridge, whom I saw some months after these terrific
murders, told me, that, forhispart, though at the time resident in London, he had not
shared in the prevailing panic;himthey effected only as a philosopher, and threw him into a
profound reverie upon the tremendous power which is laid open in a
moment to any man who can reconcile himself to the abjuration of
all conscientious restraints, if, at the same time, thoroughly
without fear. Not sharing in the public panic, however, Coleridge
did not consider that panic at all unreasonable; for, as he said
most truly in that vast metropolis there are many thousands of
households, composed exclusively of women and children; many other
thousands there are who necessarily confide their safety, in the
long evenings, to the discretion of a young servant girl; and if
she suffers herself to be beguiled by the pretence of a message
from her mother, sister, or sweetheart, into opening the door,
there, in one second of time, goes to wreck the security of the
house. However, at that time, and for many months afterwards, the
practice of steadily putting the chain upon the door before it was
opened prevailed generally, and for a long time served as a record
of that deep impression left upon London by Mr. Williams. Southey,
I may add, entered deeply into the public feeling on this occasion,
and said to me, within a week or two of the first murder, that it
was a private event of that order which rose to the dignity of a
national event. [2] But now, having prepared the reader to
appreciate on its true scale this dreadful tissue of murder (which
as a record belonging to an era that is now left forty-two years
behind us, not one person in four of this generation can be
expected to know correctly), let me pass to the circumstantial
details of the affair.Yet, first of all, one word as to the local scene of
the murders. Ratcliffe Highway is a public thoroughfare in a most
chaotic quarter of eastern or nautical London; and at this time
(viz., in 1812), when no adequate police existed except thedetectivepolice of Bow Street,
admirable for its own peculiar purposes, but utterly incommensurate
to the general service of the capital, it was a most dangerous
quarter. Every third man at the least might be set down as a
foreigner. Lascars, Chinese, Moors, Negroes, were met at every
step. And apart from the manifold ruffianism, shrouded impenetrably
under the mixed hats and turbans of men whose past was untraceable
to any European eye, it is well known that the navy (especially, in
time of war, the commercial navy) of Christendom is the sure
receptacle of all the murderers and ruffians whose crimes have
given them a motive for withdrawing themselves for a season from
the public eye. It is true, that few of this class are qualified to
act as 'able' seamen: but at all times, and especially during war,
only a small proportion (ornucleus) of each ship's company consists of such men: the large
majority being mere untutored landsmen. John Williams, however, who
had been occasionally rated as a seaman on board of various
Indiamen, &c., was probably a very accomplished seaman. Pretty
generally, in fact, he was a ready and adroit man, fertile in
resources under all sudden difficulties, and most flexibly adapting
himself to all varieties of social life. Williams was a man of
middle stature (five feet seven and a-half, to five feet eight
inches high), slenderly built, rather thin, but wiry, tolerably
muscular, and clear of all superfluous flesh. A lady, who saw him
under examination (I think at the Thames Police Office), assured me
that his hair was of the most extraordinary and vivid color, viz.,
bright yellow, something between an orange and lemon color.
Williams had been in India; chiefly in Bengal and Madras: but he
had also been upon the Indus. Now, it is notorious that, in the
Punjaub, horses of a high caste are often painted—crimson, blue,
green, purple; and it struck me that Williams might, for some
casual purpose of disguise, have taken a hint from this practice of
Scinde and Lahore, so that the color might not have been natural.
In other respects, his appearance was natural enough; and, judging
by a plaster cast of him, which I purchased in London, I should say
mean, as regarded his facial structure. One fact, however, was
striking, and fell in with the impression of his natural tiger
character, that his face wore at all times a bloodless ghastly
pallor. 'You might imagine,' said my informant, 'that in his veins
circulated not red life- blood, such as could kindle into the blush
of shame, of wrath, of pity— but a green sap that welled from no
human heart.' His eyes seemed frozen and glazed, as if their light
were all converged upon some victim lurking in the far background.
So far his appearance might have repelled; but, on the other hand,
the concurrent testimony of many witnesses, and also the silent
testimony of facts, showed that the oiliness and snaky insinuation
of his demeanor counteracted the repulsiveness of his ghastly face,
and amongst inexperienced young women won for him a very favorable
reception. In particular, one gentle-mannered girl, whom Williams
had undoubtedly designed to murder, gave in evidence—that once,
when sitting alone with her, he had said, 'Now, Miss R., supposing
that I should appear about midnight at your bedside, armed with a
carving knife, what would you say?' To which the confiding girl
had, replied, 'Oh, Mr. Williams, if it was anybody else, I should
be frightened. But, as soon as I heardyourvoice, I should be tranquil.' Poor
girl! had this outline sketch of Mr. Williams been filled in and
realized, she would have seen something in the corpse-like face,
and heard something in the sinister voice, that would have
unsettled her tranquillity for ever. But nothing short of such
dreadful experiences could avail to unmask Mr. John
Williams.Into this perilous region it was that, on a Saturday
night in December, Mr. Williams, whom we suppose to have long since
made hiscoup d'essai, forced
his way through the crowded streets, bound on business. To say, was
to do. And this night he had said to himself secretly, that he
would execute a design which he had already sketched, and which,
when finished, was destined on the following day to strike
consternation into 'all that mighty heart' of London, from centre
to circumference. It was afterwards remembered that he had quitted
his lodgings on this dark errand about eleven o'clock P. M.; not
that he meant to begin so soon: but he needed to reconnoitre. He
carried his tools closely buttoned up under his loose roomy coat.
It was in harmony with the general subtlety of his character, and
his polished hatred of brutality, that by universal agreement his
manners were distinguished for exquisite suavity: the tiger's heart
was masked by the most insinuating and snaky refinement. All his
acquaintances afterwards described his dissimulation as so ready
and so perfect, that if, in making his way through the streets,
always so crowded on a Saturday night in neighborhoods so poor, he
had accidentally jostled any person, he would (as they were all
satisfied) have stopped to offer the most gentlemanly apologies:
with his devilish heart brooding over the most hellish of purposes,
he would yet have paused to express a benign hope that the huge
mallet, buttoned up under his elegant surtout, with a view to the
little business that awaited him about ninety minutes further on,
had not inflicted any pain on the stranger with whom he had come
into collision. Titian, I believe, but certainly Rubens, and
perhaps Vandyke, made it a rule never to practise his art but in
full dress—point ruffles, bag wig, and diamond-hilted sword; and
Mr. Williams, there is reason to believe, when he went out for a
grand compound massacre (in another sense, one might have applied
to it the Oxford phrase ofgoing out as Grand
Compounder), always assumed black silk stockings
and pumps; nor would he on any account have degraded his position
as an artist by wearing a morning gown. In his second great
performance, it was particularly noticed and recorded by the one
sole trembling man, who under killing agonies of fear was compelled
(as the reader will find) from a secret stand to become the
solitary spectator of his atrocities, that Mr. Williams wore a long
blue frock, of the very finest cloth, and richly lined with silk.
Amongst the anecdotes which circulated about him, it was also said
at the time, that Mr. Williams employed the first of dentists, and
also the first of chiropodists. On no account would he patronize
any second-rate skill. And beyond a doubt, in that perilous little
branch of business which was practised by himself, he might be
regarded as the most aristocratic and fastidious of
artists.But who meantime was the victim, to whose abode he was
hurrying? For surely he never could be so indiscreet as to be
sailing about on a roving cruise in search of some chance person to
murder? Oh, no: he had suited himself with a victim some time
before, viz., an old and very intimate friend. For he seems to have
laid it down as a maxim—that the best person to murder was a
friend; and, in default of a friend, which is an article one cannot
always command, an acquaintance: because, in either case, on first
approaching his subject, suspicion would be disarmed: whereas a
stranger might take alarm, and find in the very countenance of his
murderer elect a warning summons to place himself on guard.
However, in the present ease, his destined victim was supposed to
unite both characters: originally he had been a friend; but
subsequently, on good cause arising, he had become an enemy. Or
more probably, as others said, the feelings had long since
languished which gave life to either relation of friendship or of
enmity. Marr was the name of that unhappy man, who (whether in the
character of friend or enemy) had been selected for the subject of
this present Saturday night's performance. And the story current at
that time about the connection between Williams and Marr, having
(whether true or not true) never been contradicted upon authority,
was, that they sailed in the same Indiaman to Calcutta; that they
had quarrelled when at sea; but another version of the story
said—no: they had quarrelled after returning from sea; and the
subject of their quarrel was Mrs. Marr, a very pretty young woman,
for whose favor they had been rival candidates, and at one time
with most bitter enmity towards each other. Some circumstances give
a color of probability to this story. Otherwise it has sometimes
happened, on occasion of a murder not sufficiently accounted for,
that, from pure goodness of heart intolerant of a mere sordid
motive for a striking murder, some person has forged, and the
public has accredited, a story representing the murderer as having
moved under some loftier excitement: and in this case the public,
too much shocked at the idea of Williams having on the single
motive of gain consummated so complex a tragedy, welcomed the tale
which represented him as governed by deadly malice, growing out of
the more impassioned and noble rivalry for the favor of a woman.
The case remains in some degree doubtful; but, certainly, the
probability is, that Mrs. Marr had been the true cause, thecausa teterrima, of the feud between
the men. Meantime, the minutes are numbered, the sands of the
hour-glass are running out, that measure the duration of this feud
upon earth. This night it shall cease. To-morrow is the day which
in England they call Sunday, which in Scotland they call by the
Judaic name of 'Sabbath.' To both nations, under different names,
the day has the same functions; to both it is a day of rest. For
thee also, Marr, it shall be a day of rest; so is it written; thou,
too, young Marr, shalt find rest—thou, and thy household, and the
stranger that is within thy gates. But that rest must be in the
world which lies beyond the grave. On this side the grave ye have
all slept your final sleep.The night was one of exceeding darkness; and in this humble
quarter of London, whatever the night happened to be, light or
dark, quiet or stormy, all shops were kept open on Saturday nights
until twelve o'clock, at the least, and many for half an hour
longer. There was no rigorous and pedantic Jewish superstition
about the exact limits of Sunday. At the very worst, the Sunday
stretched over from one o'clock, A. M. of one day, up to eight
o'clock A. M. of the next, making a clear circuit of thirty-one
hours. This, surely, was long enough. Marr, on this particular
Saturday night, would be content if it were even shorter, provided
it would come more quickly, for he has been toiling through sixteen
hours behind his counter. Marr's position in life was this: he kept
a little hosier's shop, and had invested in his stock and the
fittings of his shop about 180 pounds. Like all men engaged in
trade, he suffered some anxieties. He was a new beginner; but,
already, bad debts had alarmed him; and bills were coming to
maturity that were not likely to be met by commensurate sales. Yet,
constitutionally, he was a sanguine hoper. At this time he was a
stout, fresh-colored young man of twenty-seven; in some slight
degree uneasy from his commercial prospects, but still cheerful,
and anticipating—(how vainly!)—that for this night, and the next
night, at least, he will rest his wearied head and his cares upon
the faithful bosom of his sweet lovely young wife. The household of
Marr, consisting of five persons, is as follows: First, there is
himself, who, if he should happen to be ruined, in a limited
commercial sense, has energy enough to jump up again, like a
pyramid of fire, and soar high above ruin many times repeated. Yes,
poor Marr, so it might be, if thou wert left to thy native energies
unmolested; but even now there stands on the other side of the
street one born of hell, who puts his peremptory negative on all
these flattering prospects. Second in the list of his household,
stands his pretty and amiable wife, who is happy after the fashion
of youthful wives, for she is only twenty-two, and anxious (if at
all) only on account of her darling infant. For, thirdly, there is
in a cradle, not quite nine feet below the street, viz., in a warm,
cosy kitchen, and rocked at intervals by the young mother, a baby
eight months old. Nineteen months have Marr and herself been
married; and this is their first-born child. Grieve not for this
child, that it must keep the deep rest of Sunday in some other
world; for wherefore should an orphan, steeped to the lips in
poverty, when once bereaved of father and mother, linger upon an
alien and murderous earth? Fourthly, there is a stoutish boy, an
apprentice, say thirteen years old; a Devonshire boy, with handsome
features, such as most Devonshire youths have; [3] satisfied with
his place; not overworked; treated kindly, and aware that he was
treated kindly, by his master and mistress. Fifthly, and lastly,
bringing up the rear of this quiet household, is a servant girl, a
grown-up young woman; and she, being particularly kind-hearted,
occupied (as often happens in families of humble pretensions as to
rank) a sort of sisterly place in her relation to her mistress. A
great democratic change is at this very time (1854), and has been
for twenty years, passing over British society. Multitudes of
persons are becoming ashamed of saying, 'my master,' or 'my
mistress:' the term now in the slow process of superseding it is,
'my employer.' Now, in the United States, such an expression of
democratic hauteur, though disagreeable as a needless proclamation
of independence which nobody is disputing, leaves, however, no
lasting bad effect. For the domestic 'helps' are pretty generally
in a state of transition so sure and so rapid to the headship of
domestic establishments belonging to themselves, that in effect
they are but ignoring, for the present moment, a relation which
would at any rate dissolve itself in a year or two. But in England,
where no such resources exist of everlasting surplus lands, the
tendency of the change is painful. It carries with it a sullen and
a coarse expression of immunity from a yoke which was in any case a
light one, and often a benign one. In some other place I will
illustrate my meaning. Here, apparently, in Mrs. Marr's service,
the principle concerned illustrated itself practically. Mary, the
female servant, felt a sincere and unaffected respect for a
mistress whom she saw so steadily occupied with her domestic
duties, and who, though so young, and invested with some slight
authority, never exerted it capriciously, or even showed it at all
conspiciously. According to the testimony of all the neighbors, she
treated her mistress with a shade of unobtrusive respect on the one
hand, and yet was eager to relieve her, whenever that was possible,
from the weight of her maternal duties, with the cheerful voluntary
service of a sister.To this young woman it was, that, suddenly, within
three or four minutes of midnight, Marr called aloud from the head
of the stairs—directing her to go out and purchase some oysters for
the family supper. Upon what slender accidents hang oftentimes
solemn lifelong results! Marr occupied in the concerns of his shop,
Mrs. Marr occupied with some little ailment and restlessness of her
baby, had both forgotten the affair of supper; the time was now
narrowing every moment, as regarded any variety of choice; and
oysters were perhaps ordered as the likeliest article to be had at
all, after twelve o'clock should have struck. And yet, upon this
trivial circumstance depended Mary's life. Had she been sent abroad
for supper at the ordinary time of ten or eleven o'clock, it is
almost certain that she, the solitary member of the household who
escaped from the exterminating tragedy, wouldnothave escaped; too surely she would
have shared the general fate. It had now become necessary to be
quick. Hastily, therefore, receiving money from Marr with a basket
in her hand, but unbonneted, Mary tripped out of the shop. It
became afterwards, on recollection, a heart-chilling remembrance to
herself—that, precisely as she emerged from the shop-door, she
noticed, on the opposite side of the street, by the light of the
lamps, a man's figure; stationary at the instant, but in the next
instant slowly moving. This was Williams; as a little incident,
either just before or just after (at present it is impossible to
say which), sufficiently proved. Now, when one considers the
inevitable hurry and trepidation of Mary under the circumstances
stated, time barely sufficing for any chance of executing her
errand, it becomes evident that she must have connected some deep
feeling of mysterious uneasiness with the movements of this unknown
man; else, assuredly, she would not have found her attention
disposable for such a case. Thus far, she herself threw some little
light upon what it might be that, semi- consciously, was then
passing through her mind; she said, that, notwithstanding the
darkness, which would not permit her to trace the man's features,
or to ascertain the exact direction of his eyes, it yet struck her,
that from his carriage when in motion, and from the apparent
inclination of his person, he must be looking at No.
29.The little incident which I have alluded to as
confirming Mary's belief was, that, at some period not very far
from midnight, the watchman had specially noticed this stranger; he
had observed him continually peeping into the window of Marr's
shop; and had thought this act, connected with the man's
appearance, so suspicious, that he stepped into Marr's shop, and
communicated what he had seen. This fact he afterwards stated
before the magistrates; and he added, that subsequently, viz., a
few minutes after twelve (eight or ten minutes, probably, after the
departure of Mary), he (the watchman), when re-entering upon his
ordinary half-hourly beat, was requested by Marr to assist him in
closing the shutters. Here they had a final communication with each
other; and the watchman mentioned to Marr that the mysterious
stranger had now apparently taken himself off; for that he had not
been visible since the first communication made to Marr by the
watchman. There is little doubt that Williams had observed the
watchman's visit to Marr, and had thus had his attention seasonably
drawn to the indiscretion of his own demeanor; so that the warning,
given unavailingly to Marr, had been turned to account by Williams.
There can be still less doubt, that the bloodhound had commenced
his work within one minute of the watchman's assisting Marr to put
up his shutters. And on the following consideration:—that which
prevented Williams from commencing even earlier, was the exposure
of the shop's whole interior to the gaze of street passengers. It
was indispensable that the shutters should be accurately closed
before Williams could safely get to work. But, as soon as ever this
preliminary precaution had been completed, once having secured that
concealment from the public eye it then became of still greater
importance not to lose a moment by delay, than previously it had
been not to hazard any thing by precipitance. For all depended upon
going in before Marr should have locked the door. On any other mode
of effecting an entrance (as, for instance, by waiting for the
return of Mary, and making his entrance simultaneously with her),
it will be seen that Williams must have forfeited that particular
advantage which mute facts, when read into their true construction,
will soon show the reader that he must have employed. Williams
waited, of necessity, for the sound of the watchman's retreating
steps; waited, perhaps, for thirty seconds; but when that danger
was past, the next danger was, lest Marr should lock the door; one
turn of the key, and the murderer would have been locked out. In,
therefore, he bolted, and by a dexterous movement of his left hand,
no doubt, turned the key, without letting Marr perceive this fatal
stratagem. It is really wonderful and most interesting to pursue
the successive steps of this monster, and to notice the absolute
certainty with which the silent hieroglyphics of the case betray to
us the whole process and movements of the bloody drama, not less
surely and fully than if we had been ourselves hidden in Marr's
shop, or had looked down from the heavens of mercy upon this
hell-kite, that knew not what mercy meant. That he had concealed
from Marr his trick, secret and rapid, upon the lock, is evident;
because else, Marr would instantly have taken the alarm, especially
after what the watchman had communicated. But it will soon be seen
that Marr hadnotbeen alarmed.
In reality, towards the full success of Williams, it was important,
in the last degree, to intercept and forestall any yell or shout of
agony from Marr. Such an outcry, and in a situation so slenderly
fenced off from the street, viz., by walls the very thinnest, makes
itself heard outside pretty nearly as well as if it were uttered in
the street. Such an outcry it was indispensable to stifle.
Itwasstifled; and the reader
will soon understandhow.
Meantime, at this point, let us leave the murderer alone with his
victims. For fifty minutes let him work his pleasure. The
front-door, as we know, is now fastened against all help. Help
there is none. Let us, therefore, in vision, attach ourselves to
Mary; and, when all is over, let us come back withher, again raise the curtain, and read
the dreadful record of all that has passed in her
absence.The poor girl, uneasy in her mind to an extent that she
could but half understand, roamed up and down in search of an
oyster shop; and finding none that was still open, within any
circuit that her ordinary experience had made her acquainted with,
she fancied it best to try the chances of some remoter district.
Lights she saw gleaming or twinkling at a distance, that still
tempted her onwards; and thus, amongst unknown streets poorly
lighted, [4] and on a night of peculiar darkness, and in a region
of London where ferocious tumults were continually turning her out
of what seemed to be the direct course, naturally she got
bewildered. The purpose with which she started, had by this time
become hopeless. Nothing remained for her now but to retrace her
steps. But this was difficult; for she was afraid to ask directions
from chance passengers, whose appearance the darkness prevented her
from reconnoitring. At length by his lantern she recognized a
watchman; through him she was guided into the right road; and in
ten minutes more, she found herself back at the door of No. 29, in
Ratcliffe Highway. But by this time she felt satisfied that she
must have been absent for fifty or sixty minutes; indeed, she had
heard, at a distance, the cry ofpast one
o'clock, which, commencing a few seconds after
one, lasted intermittingly for ten or thirteen
minutes.In the tumult of agonizing thoughts that very soon
surprised her, naturally it became hard for her to recall
distinctly the whole succession of doubts, and jealousies, and
shadowy misgivings that soon opened upon her. But, so far as could
be collected, she had not in the first moment of reaching home
noticed anything decisively alarming. In very many cities bells are
the main instruments for communicating between the street and the
interior of houses: but in London knockers prevail. At Marr's there
was both a knocker and a bell. Mary rang, and at the same time very
gently knocked. She had no fear of disturbing her master or
mistress;themshe made sure of
finding still up. Her anxiety was for the baby, who being
disturbed, might again rob her mistress of a night's rest. And she
well knew that, with three people all anxiously awaiting her
return, and by this time, perhaps, seriously uneasy at her delay,
the least audible whisper from herself would in a moment bring one
of them to the door. Yet how is this? To her astonishment, but with
the astonishment came creeping over her an icy horror, no stir nor
murmur was heard ascending from the kitchen. At this moment came
back upon her, with shuddering anguish, the indistinct image of the
stranger in the loose dark coat, whom she had seen stealing along
under the shadowy lamp-light, and too certainly watching her
master's motions: keenly she now reproached herself that, under
whatever stress of hurry, she had not acquainted Mr. Marr with the
suspicious appearances. Poor girl! she did not then know that, if
this communication could have availed to put Marr upon his guard,
it had reached him from another quarter; so that her own omission,
which had in reality arisen under her hurry to execute her master's
commission, could not be charged with any bad consequences. But all
such reflections this way or that were swallowed up at this point
in over-mastering panic. That her double summonscouldhave been unnoticed—this solitary
fact in one moment made a revelation of horror. One person might
have fallen asleep, but two—but three—thatwas a mere impossibility. And even
supposing all three together with the baby locked in sleep, still
how unaccountable was this utter—utter silence! Most naturally at
this moment something like hysterical horror overshadowed the poor
girl, and now at last she rang the bell with the violence that
belongs to sickening terror. This done, she paused: self-command
enough she still retained, though fast and fast it was slipping
away from her, to bethink herself—that, if any overwhelming
accidenthadcompelled both Marr
and his apprentice-boy to leave the house in order to summon
surgical aid from opposite quarters—a thing barely
supposable—still, even in that case Mrs. Marr and her infant would
be left; and some murmuring reply, under any extremity, would be
elicited from the poor mother. To pause, therefore, to impose stern
silence upon herself, so as to leave room for the possible answer
to this final appeal, became a duty of spasmodic effort. Listen,
therefore, poor trembling heart; listen, and for twenty seconds be
still as death. Still as death she was: and during that dreadful
stillness, when she hushed her breath that she might listen,
occurred an incident of killing fear, that to her dying day would
never cease to renew its echoes in her ear. She, Mary, the poor
trembling girl, checking and overruling herself by a final effort,
that she might leave full opening for her dear young mistress's
answer to her own last frantic appeal, heard at last and most
distinctly a sound within the house. Yes, now beyond a doubt there
is coming an answer to her summons. What was it? On the stairs, not
the stairs that led downwards to the kitchen, but the stairs that
led upwards to the single story of bed-chambers above, was heard a
creaking sound. Next was heard most distinctly a footfall: one,
two, three, four, five stairs were slowly and distinctly descended.
Then the dreadful footsteps were heard advancing along the little
narrow passage to the door. The steps—oh heavens!whosesteps?—have paused at the door.
The very breathing can be heard of that dreadful being, who has
silenced all breathing except his own in the house. There is but a
door between him and Mary. What is he doing on the other side of
the door? A cautious step, a stealthy step it was that came down
the stairs, then paced along the little narrow passage—narrow as a
coffin—till at last the step pauses at the door. How hard the
fellow breathes! He, the solitary murderer, is on one side the
door; Mary is on the other side. Now, suppose that he should
suddenly open the door, and that incautiously in the dark Mary
should rush in, and find herself in the arms of the murderer. Thus
far the case is a possible one—that to a certainty, had this little
trick been tried immediately upon Mary's return, it would have
succeeded; had the door been opened suddenly upon her first
tingle-tingle, headlong she would have tumbled in, and perished.
But now Mary is upon her guard. The unknown murderer and she have
both their lips upon the door, listening, breathing hard; but
luckily they are on different sides of the door; and upon the least
indication of unlocking or unlatching, she would have recoiled into
the asylum of general darkness.What was the murderer's meaning in coming along the passage
to the front door? The meaning was this: separately, as an
individual, Mary was worth nothing at all to him. But, considered
as a member of a household, she had this value, viz., that she, if
caught and murdered, perfected and rounded the desolation of the
house. The case being reported, as reported it would be all over
Christendom, led the imagination captive. The whole covey of
victims was thus netted; the household ruin was thus full and
orbicular; and in that proportion the tendency of men and women,
flutter as they might, would be helplessly and hopelessly to sink
into the all-conquering hands of the mighty murderer. He had but to
say—my testimonials are dated from No. 29 Ratcliffe Highway, and
the poor vanquished imagination sank powerless before the
fascinating rattlesnake eye of the murderer. There is not a doubt
that the motive of the murderer for standing on the inner side of
Marr's front-door, whilst Mary stood on the outside, was—a hope
that, if he quietly opened the door, whisperingly counterfeiting
Marr's voice, and saying, What made you stay so long? possibly she
might have been inveigled. He was wrong; the time was past for
that; Mary was now maniacally awake; she began now to ring the bell
and to ply the knocker with unintermitting violence. And the
natural consequence was, that the next door neighbor, who had
recently gone to bed and instantly fallen asleep, was roused; and
by the incessant violence of the ringing and the knocking, which
now obeyed a delirious and uncontrollable impulse in Mary, he
became sensible that some very dreadful event must be at the root
of so clamorous an uproar. To rise, to throw up the sash, to demand
angrily the cause of this unseasonable tumult, was the work of a
moment. The poor girl remained sufficiently mistress of herself
rapidly to explain the circumstance of her own absence for an hour;
her belief that Mr. and Mrs. Marr's family had all been murdered in
the interval; and that at this very moment the murderer was in the
house.The person to whom she addressed this statement was a
pawnbroker; and a thoroughly brave man he must have been; for it
was a perilous undertaking, merely as a trial of physical strength,
singly to face a mysterious assassin, who had apparently signalized
his prowess by a triumph so comprehensive. But, again, for the
imagination it required an effort of self-conquest to rush headlong
into the presence of one invested with a cloud of mystery, whose
nation, age, motives, were all alike unknown. Rarely on any field
of battle has a soldier been called upon to face so complex a
danger. For if the entire family of his neighbor Marr had been
exterminated, were this indeed true, such a scale of bloodshed
would seem to argue that there must have been two persons as the
perpetrators; or if one singly had accomplished such a ruin, in
that case how colossal must have been his audacity! probably, also,
his skill and animal power! Moreover, the unknown enemy (whether
single or double) would, doubtless, be elaborately armed. Yet,
under all these disadvantages, did this fearless man rush at once
to the field of butchery in his neighbor's house. Waiting only to
draw on his trousers, and to arm himself with the kitchen poker, he
went down into his own little back-yard. On this mode of approach,
he would have a chance of intercepting the murderer; whereas from
the front there would be no such chance; and there would also be
considerable delay in the process of breaking open the door. A
brick wall, nine or ten feet high, divided his own back premises
from those of Marr. Over this he vaulted; and at the moment when he
was recalling himself to the necessity of going back for a candle,
he suddenly perceived a feeble ray of light already glimmering on
some part of Marr's premises. Marr's back-door stood wide open.
Probably the murderer had passed through it one half minute before.
Rapidly the brave man passed onwards to the shop, and there beheld
the carnage of the night stretched out on the floor, and the narrow
premises so floated with gore, that it was hardly possible to
escape the pollution of blood in picking out a path to the
front-door. In the lock of the door still remained the key which
had given to the unknown murderer so fatal an advantage over his
victims. By this time, the heart- shaking news involved in the
outcries of Mary (to whom it occurred that by possibility some one
out of so many victims might still be within the reach of medical
aid, but that all would depend upon speed) had availed, even at
that late hour, to gather a small mob about the house. The
pawnbroker threw open the door. One or two watchmen headed the
crowd; but the soul-harrowing spectacle checked them, and impressed
sudden silence upon their voices, previously so loud. The tragic
drama read aloud its own history, and the succession of its several
steps—few and summary. The murderer was as yet altogether unknown;
not even suspected. But there were reasons for thinking that he
must have been a person familiarly known to Marr. He had entered
the shop by opening the door after it had been closed by Marr. But
it was justly argued—that, after the caution conveyed to Marr by
the watchman, the appearance of any stranger in the shop at that
hour, and in so dangerous a neighborhood, and entering by so
irregular and suspicious a course, (i.e., walking in after the door had
been closed, and after the closing of the shutters had cut off all
open communication with the street), would naturally have roused
Marr to an attitude of vigilance and self-defence. Any indication,
therefore, that Marr hadnotbeen so roused, would argue to a certainty thatsomethinghad occurred to neutralize
this alarm, and fatally to disarm the prudent jealousies of Marr.
But this 'something' could only have lain in one simple fact, viz.,
that the person of the murderer was familiarly known to Marr as
that of an ordinary and unsuspected acquaintance. This being
presupposed as the key to all the rest, the whole course and
evolution of the subsequent drama becomes clear as daylight. The
murderer, it is evident, had opened gently, and again closed behind
him with equal gentleness, the street-door. He had then advanced to
the little counter, all the while exchanging the ordinary
salutation of an old acquaintance with the unsuspecting Marr.
Having reached the counter, he would then ask Marr for a pair of
unbleached cotton socks. In a shop so small as Marr's, there could
be no great latitude of choice for disposing of the different
commodities. The arrangement of these had no doubt become familiar
to the murderer; and he had already ascertained that, in order to
reach down the particular parcel wanted at present, Marr would find
it requisite to face round to the rear, and, at the same moment, to
raise his eyes and his hands to a level eighteen inches above his
own head. This movement placed him in the most disadvantageous
possible position with regard to the murderer, who now, at the
instant when Marr's hands and eyes were embarrassed, and the back
of his head fully exposed, suddenly from below his large surtout,
had unslung a heavy ship-carpenter's mallet, and, with one solitary
blow, had so thoroughly stunned his victim, as to leave him
incapable of resistance. The whole position of Marr told its own
tale. He had collapsed naturally behind the counter, with his hands
so occupied as to confirm the whole outline of the affair as I have
here suggested it. Probable enough it is that the very first blow,
the first indication of treachery that reached Marr, would also be
the last blow as regarded the abolition of consciousness. The
murderer's plan andrationale